- It's that time of the year again! Just kidding, we were late.
Click here to see the awards and nominate people for the rest of the categories.
- We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!
Monster Hunter World Mafia - Game Thread
- Thread starter Grammaton
- Start date
- Status
damn am I completely off.
usually u do some obv things to make yourself seen as town.
Breh I voted and was voting for poyser all phase until I voted you. No one joined or wanted to join.
yes stuff like thatYou mean like tell everyone how I rolecrushed Ratchet when he tried to kill me and it got him killed instead in the OP mafia game
or "I'm town"
Arne Slot
The Shiny One
hime
Exceptional
what?
Its interesting to me that most of us familiar with Flower's style and behavior from a fair amount of past games played with her were noting she was not really operating her normal self in this game when she was a townie like in other games. Also weird how she keeps committing to confirm reads, thoughts, and bouncing off her views to you a LOT in day 1 and day 2 and this is just mainly day 1. There's like 0 suspicion from either of you toward each other where as others, yours truly, have pointed out she's been generally less nuanced in her town play then is typical.
Its trigger a little bit of red flag to me, more so toward her, then you, about how much she kept deferring to you for validation. Or do you think I'm mistaken on this?
Arne Slot
The Shiny One
I said "flower seems okay for now" because I opened the game by voting her lol
Yes I have pointed out multiple times how much she has deferred to me. I've been obvtown from the jump tho tbf
I know you voted for her right after I think Tweet did, it could be her trying not to be a wolf but it just pinged weird. She never pushed back on you or Poyser for sussing her and called it normal townie behavior, which is odd given past games how much she'd become frantic when pushed for a potential lynch in past games. But most of her game has been similar to your approach, your reads, your behavior. Not a little weird to you?
can also see if one of them is scum they aren't teammates
magic & hime
magic kept trying to shut down the recruit talk and one line he said stood out that made sense for GoT theme wise but not here.
I agree with him on that but unless u know the lore here that might be a TMI on his part slip.
magic & hime
magic kept trying to shut down the recruit talk and one line he said stood out that made sense for GoT theme wise but not here.
I agree with him on that but unless u know the lore here that might be a TMI on his part slip.
I've seen it and I'm not really feeling red flags on YOUR slot regarding this, just hers, if I'm not communicating this clearly enough.
Arne Slot
The Shiny One
I don't think you were trying to shade me, you asked me if I agreed with you about her being deferential so I was showing you that yes I made the same point earlier and am not really town reading her atm
To be fair Flower is a serial sheeper and I can easily see her doing this rather easily as town.
Arne Slot
The Shiny One
actually I did like this post earlier this phase, I don't sense a scum agenda here, and I do think the dalton slot is likely scum.
pausing at page 30 cuz got alot to talk about,
first, raem is some sort of scum this game - fits mafia or serial killer. i'll evidence so with quotes below each point
1. raem initially voted tpein with practically no reason. basically a vote to get things rolling. raem at the time had no real town reads / discredit meta town reads, and had not engaged in any meaningful game solving interaction
2. raem pivots to pretty easy scum reads with no resistance to them - xadlin, hime, tpein. he votes tpein to move things forward but the moment tpein made 2 posts (without addressing raem AT ALL), raem simply moved to hime without commenting on tpein's posts AT ALL
3. raem's last scum read at the time was xadlin, who did not offer much in the thread readwise. however, notice how raem is accusing xadlin of something that he himself was doing?? flavor talk.
not only that, but xadlin had a scum read on hime. this is important because raem also scum reads hime. raem did not make any comment about this mutual scum read when addressing xadlin.
4. here xadlin votes hime but also says that he is willing to go back to suspecting raem. guess who died night 1? xadlin. why? because he suspected the right player. its raem or hime. one of them serial, another mafia. one of them killed him. neither of them cared to respond to this as far as im concerned up to page 30. why? because they have the ability to remove him at night.
a counter argument would be that hime will kill ultra instead, but this is too obvious. it brings attention to herself. killing xadlin is much more safer. the same can be said for raem, except nobody other than xadlin actually showed much suspicion on raem up to this point. imposter did a bit but it was a comment about stopping the flavor solving rather than suspicion. in fact imposter is now dead so it is entirely possible that raem took him out aswell after xadlin.
5. the last point i wanna make here (and this points more to raem maybe being mafia) is that raem tmi'd magic's general directions as "lynching townies" but has not once established why he reads any of the directions magic was pushing as town. magic was onto tpein and lethal at the time, both players raem was fine with lynching. in fact raem scum read and voted tpein himself, so where is this comment about magic leading town lynches coming from? this is very ingenuine. but not just town ingenuine, this is scum ingenuine.
first proper scum read this game - raem
first, raem is some sort of scum this game - fits mafia or serial killer. i'll evidence so with quotes below each point
1. raem initially voted tpein with practically no reason. basically a vote to get things rolling. raem at the time had no real town reads / discredit meta town reads, and had not engaged in any meaningful game solving interaction
Checkers or go fish?
I've been setting up a shopify store since I've come home.Use to using other website builder stuff so slight learning curve setting up payments and shit. I've been keeping up though like adhd checking the thread time to time. Nothing strikes me as "oh scum".
Slow day game discussion wise despite 32 pages. Disappointing that the main thing was just The Impostor commenting on flavor speculation. Lot of scared players on the sideline, so hunter instinct is telling me something there. But again feel like Magic and see him trying to force discussion and nothing is coming from it.
Might just throw my vote on Tpein to get things rolling more.
[Vote Lynch Tpein]
2. raem pivots to pretty easy scum reads with no resistance to them - xadlin, hime, tpein. he votes tpein to move things forward but the moment tpein made 2 posts (without addressing raem AT ALL), raem simply moved to hime without commenting on tpein's posts AT ALL
Kinda biased towards Lethal since he has a red dead avatar.I don't find him suspicious yet.
Unusual though for once I'm town reading people left and right. Game feels slooow as fuck.
I'm fine with pressuring xadlin, hime, tpein.
3. raem's last scum read at the time was xadlin, who did not offer much in the thread readwise. however, notice how raem is accusing xadlin of something that he himself was doing?? flavor talk.
not only that, but xadlin had a scum read on hime. this is important because raem also scum reads hime. raem did not make any comment about this mutual scum read when addressing xadlin.
4. here xadlin votes hime but also says that he is willing to go back to suspecting raem. guess who died night 1? xadlin. why? because he suspected the right player. its raem or hime. one of them serial, another mafia. one of them killed him. neither of them cared to respond to this as far as im concerned up to page 30. why? because they have the ability to remove him at night.
a counter argument would be that hime will kill ultra instead, but this is too obvious. it brings attention to herself. killing xadlin is much more safer. the same can be said for raem, except nobody other than xadlin actually showed much suspicion on raem up to this point. imposter did a bit but it was a comment about stopping the flavor solving rather than suspicion. in fact imposter is now dead so it is entirely possible that raem took him out aswell after xadlin.
5. the last point i wanna make here (and this points more to raem maybe being mafia) is that raem tmi'd magic's general directions as "lynching townies" but has not once established why he reads any of the directions magic was pushing as town. magic was onto tpein and lethal at the time, both players raem was fine with lynching. in fact raem scum read and voted tpein himself, so where is this comment about magic leading town lynches coming from? this is very ingenuine. but not just town ingenuine, this is scum ingenuine.
first proper scum read this game - raem
- Status