Monster Hunter World Mafia - Game Thread

[Flower]

Why? Do you have actual reasons?

I've mentioned them multiple times by now and that read hasn't changed.

 

[Ultra]

good post, tho i'll reference this point - hime can actually make spontaneos desicions without discussing in scum chat. she did so in fairy tail by claiming voyeru out of nowehre to say she targeted her teammate and saw a roelblock on them

if cp has me on ignore someone can convey this to him

don't bother im prepping my daykill rn

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

Tweet almost certainly town
Idk how as scum he thinks he’s coming in today after that flip and pushing me as scum

Then again tho I think that post may have been pre written, and obviously he wouldn’t be expecting hime to die lol

Ye it was pre written

Can you direct me towards your posts that clear you from being teamed with hime? My phone battery isn't gonna make it much longer and I dread rereading d3

 

[Poyser]

there is some problems with this, people kept thinking i am a watcher, not a protective role
also hime did have me in her scum reads pretty early on, tho never touched about if its claim related until she cc'ed me

I don’t think that’s right, I ISOd hime and barely found any mentions of you at all lol.
Idk why anybody thought you were a watcher. I know magic said he thought so but I think hime just sheeped her reason off that, because the speculation since d2 is that you were protective and basically confirmed it yourself. Magic apparently got confused because he sees watcher as protective, but it made no sense for hime to think you were the watcher lol

 

[RÆM]

Thank you for the game @Grammaton

 

[Emil]

don't bother im prepping my daykill rn

take evans out pls lets goo

just turn brain off and yeet evans

 

[Tempest]

correction: magic wasn't arguing for lynching ekko. immaterial to the rest of my post tho

 

[Ultra]

take evans out pls lets goo

just turn brain off and yeet evans

In all seriousness he does need to get yeeted

But I'm playing both sides so I'll have to daykill a townie to make up for it

[Vote lynch Evans]

 

[Emil]

In all seriousness he does need to get yeeted

But I'm playing both sides so I'll have to daykill a townie to make up for it

[Vote lynch Evans]

i'll do u 1 better

day kill evans, if he flips town - lynch alco
if he flips scum we lynch magic maybe.. or poyser.. whichver ... fook

 

[Tempest]

Out of curiosity what do you guys actually base SK spec on

your play isn't really lining up with your town or scum play. yeah you had a case on hime early on but you didn't push it hard and got talked off of it easily enough and then didn't really try to do much else. feels like you didn't want to turn over any more stones and risk negative attention from scum. could be wrong, it's a SK read. anyone could be SK technically, even someone with a proven role!

did you want to claim a different role or is this your final answer?

 

[Ultra]

i'll do u 1 better

day kill evans, if he flips town - lynch alco
if he flips scum we lynch magic maybe.. or poyser.. whichver ... fook

I'll have to see if it checks out with my secondary headhunter wincon

 

[Flower]

@CraigPelton @Poyser what do you make of Alco? Do you have any read on him?

 

[Magic]

Votes Hime after I CC the CC. Cool, sounds like we'll definitely get a lynch here, right?

Says he trusts me, like he did with T-Pein. Cool, sounds like we'll definitely get a lynch here, right?

WAIT A SEC HOLD UP I DON'T TRUST YOU ANYMORE CP OUTTA NOWHERE


Evans comes in and lynches ekko, won't lynch hime because of the reasons Magic (his scum read, btw!) gave



arguing with me, so much trust



Magic likes this post, emboldening Evans' garbage stand against voting hime

argues for lynching ekko first even though we literally have evidence ekko visited me n1 and nothing bad happened

agreeing with evans, wants to let scum resolve hime


think magic liked this one too, maybe not



HOPS off of hime





magic doesn't even engage with the blatant contradictions I'm pointing out about evans who is voting him btw

I pose this question to hime

magic says lynch me instead of hime

again, scum should resolve

hime has no answer at all for my question.



magic concedes hime's defense is shit. this should be the end of it right??

nope, he hops off again! where'd the trust in me go? hime has only made herself look worse by this point!



doesn't want to no lynch, doesn't want to lynch hime, doesn't want to lynch ekko, there's like 1-2 hours left in day. this is fucking shite.


now hime suddenly has an answer for me. coached? magic did speculate poyser was coaching people earlier. poyser definitely wasn't around for this exchange, but magic was!







worth noting that hime did give reads at EOD after deadline had passed with a no-lynch

wants to have another go-round on this argument circle as if I haven't already explained all of this.











again magic hops off. deadline passes. he hops back on. hime shows up and gives reads like he said she should.

yes @Magic you did hop off. repeatedly. yes the no-lynch was your fault. you were constantly indecisive and emboldened people's cases for hime being town. you kept arguing in circles with me after repeatedly saying you would trust me, creating doubt and clogging up the thread. you also kept engaging ekko in conversation to entertain his dumbass ideas and clog up the thread even more.

town or scum you need to take the L on this.

my only reason for thinking magic might not be scum: surely he could've coached hime better than this from the get-go.

my explanation for it: hime may conduct herself like psychic as scum where she doesn't really read the scum QT and collaborate before coming into the thread and impulsively responding to stuff. so she gives the shitty answer, I destroy it, she checks the QT and suddenly has a better answer. too little, too late.

I'm not gonna lie and argue against this because I honestly thought I voted her again after i unvoted. i dont even remember the unvote.

that's my bad.

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

why town and not SK?

Wow, is that the question you needed so urgently answered?

Anyone except Evans and maybe CP can be SK imo but that's not something anyone ever needs to qualify their reads with

 

[Ultra]

your play isn't really lining up with your town or scum play. yeah you had a case on hime early on but you didn't push it hard and got talked off of it easily enough and then didn't really try to do much else. feels like you didn't want to turn over any more stones and risk negative attention from scum. could be wrong, it's a SK read. anyone could be SK technically, even someone with a proven role!

did you want to claim a different role or is this your final answer?

This sounds like the kind of post Ekko would write, but let's say for arguments sake you suspect me of being SK - where do you intend to go from here?

 

[Poyser]

This sounds like the kind of post Ekko would write, but let's say for arguments sake you suspect me of being SK - where do you intend to go from here?

Dude it’s mass claim, so you need to claim

 

[Emil]

Wow, is that the question you needed so urgently answered?

Anyone except Evans and maybe CP can be SK imo but that's not something anyone ever needs to qualify their reads with

i cant be sk unless i have ninja

or i guess i failed a kill on cp.. tho none claimed protecting him

given evan is likely scum, mafia knows i am seraph since n1 anyway

 

[Emil]

Dude it’s mass claim, so you need to claim

"why dont u claim first scumboi" - tpein

 

[Poyser]

Why did hime protect tweet n1 btw

 

[Ultra]

Dude it’s mass claim, so you need to claim

I understand what it means lol