No, its not. Your argument hinges on a hypothetical when it would be more sound for me or scum to shoot someone who would NEVER get lynched like Gram or Flower. Your still in POE, so is Frinckles, and Gad with me and even on the fringes so is Nibel. You also went along with mislynching RDK so no, I'm not buying the belief Gram was protected by Jinri. Even when potentially offered a lifeline by Gram to help lynch RDK, I didn't buy his claim or argument to surround the miscalculation that he wasn't at fault and looks more like proactive backpedaling to not be held accountable for leading the lynch on our one and only town tracker.
Add that with Nibel's lying about using Sky's ability from her corpse when town tracker (RDK) got lynched and couldn't follow or track him to see if he's lying or not. On top of that, RDK caught and forced Gad to admit he was lying about being VT while the latter played semantics to weasel out of it.
So it comes down to this:
Nibels + Magic + Gad
or
Nibels + Magic + You
or
Nibels + Magic + Gram
NIbels is 100% scum and if you help me lynch him you will see that. The only potentiality he isn't scum is if his result was tampered with and I fucking doubt it, he's just lying.