• We are currently rolling out incremental alterations to the forum. Don't freak! You aren't going crazy.

Game Ranked My Hero Academia Mafia Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

Rugrat

Caldust
Town have hime and Fang, both killing utility roles. You're also adding this odd night Vig part now when really, given the suspicion on your slot, you should have done so earlier when it looks less like an attempt to navigate the argument against your claim.
This is just utter rubbish. There never was any after I claimed and in 99% of games there shouldn’t be any.
 

Ultra

THE BEAR
Moderator
I have lots of reservations about a setup with a hated townie plus Mafia having a poison plus a Hider, plus 5 scum, plus a serial killer. Like jeez that's rough. I do think he's probably not scum claiming it though.

All of the prominent mafia flavors have flipped, so there's technically room here (if Rug is to be believed) that they're already wiped and we just have an SK on the table, don't really know about that one though
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
I'm Ingenium, 2 shot rally. Rally let's me do one of two things - I can either given them two vote power for the next day phase, or motivate them next night phase, giving them an extra usage. Apparently if they have multiple roles, one is upgraded at random.

So, obviously if I use my vote power increase on scum at the wrong time, it could end up giving them a majority lynch early, with a hated on top of that is really, really rough. I do think my ability is meant to be a counter to the vote block, temporary though it may be.

Abstained night 2 and used my motivate on Nibel night 3, which means he should be able to jail two people night 4. Figured I should motivate him or hime, opted for him because there was too much unknown about what it could do for hime.
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
This is just utter rubbish. There never was any after I claimed and in 99% of games there shouldn’t be any.
Your slot was in the PoE, your thread play has been to defend scum basically so not much good there, so yes there was suspicion on your slot and there still is. The number of killing roles was brought into question yesterday too, you're rewriting history here.

If this is the best your defence is going to be, you should save your time and try and figure out a solve somewhere.
 

Ultra

THE BEAR
Moderator
I'm Ingenium, 2 shot rally. Rally let's me do one of two things - I can either given them two vote power for the next day phase, or motivate them next night phase, giving them an extra usage. Apparently if they have multiple roles, one is upgraded at random.

So, obviously if I use my vote power increase on scum at the wrong time, it could end up giving them a majority lynch early, with a hated on top of that is really, really rough. I do think my ability is meant to be a counter to the vote block, temporary though it may be.

Abstained night 2 and used my motivate on Nibel night 3, which means he should be able to jail two people night 4. Figured I should motivate him or hime, opted for him because there was too much unknown about what it could do for hime.

Nibel's going to miss twice isn't he
 

Rugrat

Caldust
Your slot was in the PoE, your thread play has been to defend scum basically so not much good there, so yes there was suspicion on your slot and there still is. The number of killing roles was brought into question yesterday too, you're rewriting history here.

If this is the best your defence is going to be, you should save your time and try and figure out a solve somewhere.
I’ve already said I’m finding a solve.

But it’s dumb to try and present a vig withholding their shots from their claim, as some kind of gotcha.
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
All of the prominent mafia flavors have flipped, so there's technically room here (if Rug is to be believed) that they're already wiped and we just have an SK on the table, don't really know about that one though
I'm going to be insufferable if there are only 4 mafia, but yeah maybe. Still think it's Poyser though, I mean it's more killing power on top of more investigation power basically at the strength of an inverse Hider. Also don't think anything Rugrat has said has been particularly compelling so both can easily be scum imo. Rugrat probably not Mafia, obviously
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
I’ve already said I’m finding a solve.

But it’s dumb to try and present a vig withholding their shots from their claim, as some kind of gotcha.
It's dumb to withhold this when transparency is sorely required, and then reveal it when part of the argument against you is the number of killing power roles the town has being hard to reconcile, and then act shocked that you get suspected for it. When you withhold parts of your claim, you do so with implicit risk - it's up to you to weigh that risk up. In some cases, it backfires, this being one - you can't have your cake and eat it too.
 
Day 4 vote count 1

Flower

Future Society
V.I.P. Member

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
Basically if only one of Poyser and Rugrat dies today, then he can block the other, and one of Dofla/Gad. Assuming that one scum has flipped then that should be at least one kill stopped, and if not, then the SK is solved along with one Mafia stopped.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top