Game Ranked My Hero Academia Mafia Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

Ratchet

Resplendent
Advisor
But ya I'd appreciate some unbiased feedback from folks that don't just care about the ladder if they think this should be switched to unranked.

Apologies for the shit hosting and oversight on some roles. You can whine at me if you'd like, I'm aware of it.
I think if there is a recruit in the game it should be unranked. Generally, I don't want to have what is ranked/unranked policed too hard because I already find the formula to be too stringent and restrictive of creativity. The kills could make the game very swingy so I dunno how much I love the balance, but there was consideration for most of this so I'd be okay with it. Just the recruit would be a deal breaker.
 

Magic

Resplendent
Also scum fakes were meant to have overlap with town that had plenty of overlap to muddle things and insread they just didn't claim my fakes saying they couldn't be used. Which ya know is what it is but I would have liked to see what happened.
 

Ratchet

Resplendent
Advisor
I didn't mislynch a single player and successfully associated my cop shot on the scum aesthetic (Tempest). Do cry more sour grapes if you want too, even Hime admitted our roles on paper sounded too similar and she isn't malding about it like you are.
I'm malding because it was difficult to solve through, makes absolutely no sense to kill without declaring you'll shoot her.
 

Magic

Resplendent
I think if there is a recruit in the game it should be unranked. Generally, I don't want to have what is ranked/unranked policed too hard because I already find the formula to be too stringent and restrictive of creativity. The kills could make the game very swingy so I dunno how much I love the balance, but there was consideration for most of this so I'd be okay with it. Just the recruit would be a deal breaker.
Sk had no real fake-able role, I would have announced a successful recruit, and the recruit was optional.
 

Aurelian

Titan
Administrator
Decepticon
I'm malding because it was difficult to solve through, makes absolutely no sense to kill without declaring you'll shoot her.
You already know I will NEVER listen to you directing me so I always discard anything you say about trying to instruct me, on top of that with RDK flipping the equivalent to scum godfather proxy and his fake claim being outted as a lie when he said he was the cop, Rugrat shooting me wasn't exactly ideal either but you guys lynched him anyways
 

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
But ya I'd appreciate some unbiased feedback from folks that don't just care about the ladder if they think this should be switched to unranked.

Apologies for the shit hosting and oversight on some roles. You can whine at me if you'd like, I'm aware of it.
I’m not really a fan of switching games to unranked after the fact tbh. At the end of the day the system we have is there for a reason and it helps but it’s hardly perfect and bad games will still happen. never gonna get completely neutral feedback after the fact
 

Ratchet

Resplendent
Advisor
I think ratcheted whined about this when he thought there was 5 scum players and it's just that. Players need to know when to hold them.
Uh, I said I had reservations about it and was also arguing that I thought there were 4, and was told there would definitely be 5.
 

Gaddamnit

NYC Pizza is better than Neopolitan fite me
Pronouns
He/Him
Bro, this game was literally Nipples throwing dick at me while y'all narrow me down based on other plays
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top