• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked My Hero Academia Mafia Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Ratchet said:
Vote: Tempest

I've skimmed over the majority of Day 1, like this the best. I'd like to give Ultra his lynch, firstly, as I've mostly agreed with what he has been saying. In addition, some of CP, er, "Tempest"'s positions and statements have rang untrue to me - one such case that I remember is where he implied that he searched through multiple past games to find how Watson typically approached and read Fang, I don't really buy this for a second because it's not something I think he would ever take much interest in, and I certainly don't see him going above in that way to check a point that's ultimately not going to help him solve.

GTH I would have Gad as scum too. Not really buying anything he's selling, especially his push (or rather, his support of RDK's push) on Flower where he didn't seem at all interested in considering things like Flower's personality or established history before co-opting it.

I'll try and get a full reads list together shortly, but happy with Watson, Gram, Emil, Cubey, Flower, Bachi and Ultra as town. Happy with, but less so, with hime and Mango.
Click to expand...
eh? I search past games all the time and did so here. she has analyzed aurelian before and has never just thrown out a read without any forethought. I have caught her for this exact thing. this is a shit reason to vote me
 
Ratchet said:
So, is this the grand case then? I don't see what's so good about it? It should be noted that this came before Reloaded flipped, so if we're going with uncharitable interpretations, this could very easily be him tying Ekko to a scum mate. In fact, isn't that exactly what scum would be doing there?

The first point he makes is a lack of "follow up" from Ekko in seeking a claim. While this is ultimately fair, it doesn't really suggest he must be scum, especially when you consider Ekko's personality. He can be very tenacious, but he's also inclined to follow his own direction, which Reloaded was not. Then he tries to establish a "gotcha" on Ekko by saying Ekko first wanted a claim, and then said he was good with a claim, which someone means he could be scum? I don't understand that point at all. And then the rest is just saying that Ekko has TMI for being right. Which, yeah, possible, but you can make that argument for anything anyone says if you try hard enough. In this post, I don't really see any attempt from CP to establish whether it is TMI or not without much regard for whether it's plausible for him to believe as town or even why he approaches it this way as scum. His conclusion is convenient - he gives an example of why Ekko might not have been all-in on Reloaded from the start, and then frames that as scummy, and then ties him right to Reloaded. Doesn't inspire confidence in me at all.
Click to expand...
this is such a bad faith interpretation of that case lol, you are fitting everything into your preconceived decision to push me
 
Dr. Watson said:
@Poyser

I'm down for an Elmo lunch my main gripe with straight up scum reading him fully is his approach this game is very hardcore and he tends to really try this hard as town. But the points he's been making recently are... heavily speculative. So, soft scum lean, not opposed, but he's been playing within his town range
Thoughts?

I'm 50/50 on Gad but he's so LHF and it's easy for his reactions to be weaponized against him. But he seems frustrated and it makes it harder to determine whether to read into that frustration. Fucks his reads too. If I were to ISO flower vs gad rn I'd only find a bunch of "no you" tier posts. Not worth it

No to CP lynch, I want him to cook
My soft sidedness appeases irl again
Click to expand...
 
Tempest said:
not worth the trade off of mafia being in the dark and wasting roles on me
Click to expand...
don't really agree with this. town can solve the game with roles that would be wasted on you because you didn't claim. I think the trade off is worth it
 
I asked for thoughts on CP and you have "I want him to cook". Forgive me but I don't think that meets what I was looking for.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RDK
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top