Game Ranked My Hero Academia Mafia Thread

[Poyser]

Yeah exactly, he made a big show of things after his result was not only proven wrong but there's godfather in a remaining pool of scum

Feels like he was making a show of things

Considering the grief you’ve given me about cp and fang interacting it’s kinda weird you just dismiss rdk faking a wrong result on his teammate if he’s scum

 

[Ultra]

No he doesn't

Fuck off

Like not only would there be an indeterminate method of him having another flipped result but there's a default possibility of about 50% that he would have hit godfather, how does this level of confidence and indignation make sense

Screams "Look at me I'm OBVIOUS cop"

 

[MangoSenpai]

I won’t vig you and I don’t want your lynch though fwiw

But.. you literally did say you wanted to lynch me?

I’ve had a look, and think Mango is probably the direction for today.

I think he’s SK but I’d rather get rid of Mango

 

[Ultra]

Considering the grief you’ve given me about cp and fang interacting it’s kinda weird you just dismiss rdk faking a wrong result on his teammate if he’s scum

Those situations aren't equivalent though.

 

[Poyser]

In what world is the odds of hitting the godfather 50% lol

 

[Poyser]

Those situations aren't equivalent though.

Yeah, the one you’re proposing is way worse

 

[MangoSenpai]

Those situations aren't equivalent though.

Can you give me a second opinion on what Rugrat's doing rn?

 

[Ultra]

Your argument is that Aurelian and CP did theatre to prove a claim that wasn't even worth proving

I only need to assume RDK was seeding a cop claim, Watson didn't even need to do anything.

 

[Poyser]

I don’t think what you’re pushing makes any sense. If I’m the cop and I see my result flips and it was wrong, my first assumption wouldn’t be “my role is faulty I can’t trust it” it would be “guess I was messed with”. Theres no reason to assume he shouldn’t trust his town result lol

 

[Ultra]

Yeah, the one you’re proposing is way worse

All it really requires is the argument you presented which is that they would be confident in being able to claim cop

 

[Poyser]

Your argument is that Aurelian and CP did theatre to prove a claim that wasn't even worth proving

I only need to assume RDK was seeding a cop claim, Watson didn't even need to do anything.

Seeding an innocent on his scum mate that’s not the godfather

Give it up

 

[Ratchet]

Given RDK was last claim odds both Aurelian is SK and RDK is scum scooping cop claim?

Pretty much where I'm at.

 

[Grammaton]

All it really requires is the argument you presented which is that they would be confident in being able to claim cop

There are still unclaimed players tho?

 

[Ultra]

I don’t think what you’re pushing makes any sense. If I’m the cop and I see my result flips and it was wrong, my first assumption wouldn’t be “my role is faulty I can’t trust it” it would be “guess I was messed with”. Theres no reason to assume he shouldn’t trust his town result lol

This is basic math Poyser

If RDK sees Watson flip, what does that imply? Probably Lawyer, or Bus Driver. And there's godfather too. So between all these scenarios you have at the very best a 50% chance your result is reliable.

 

[Poyser]

All it really requires is the argument you presented which is that they would be confident in being able to claim cop

How is that even slightly equivalent. When I was proposing it, all he was explaining is a “no result”, hardly an innocent on somebody that’s flipped mafia with no investigation immunity which would be pretty stupid

 

[Ratchet]

Tbf

If it’s fake why is he faking an incorrect result on a teammate who ain’t even the GF lolol

This is also fair, and I don't really have a good explanation.

 

[Poyser]

This is basic math Poyser

If RDK sees Watson flip, what does that imply? Probably Lawyer, or Bus Driver. And there's godfather too. So between all these scenarios you have at the very best a 50% chance your result is reliable.

Not if you’re hitting town which is the result he got. Your math ain’t mathing. How many town players are in the game?

 

[Ultra]

There are still unclaimed players tho?

Sure, strictly speaking, but only a handful, and I think it wouldn't be hard to piece together none of them are cop, between what's presented and available information. Can lay this out more explicitly if you want

 

[Ultra]

Tbf

If it’s fake why is he faking an incorrect result on a teammate who ain’t even the GF lolol

Well it wasn't fake until she was vigged now was she?

 

[Poyser]

In a bubble if you get a town result the odds of you hitting the godfather out of everyone are pretty slim. Obviously it happens, but there’s just no way it’s what you’d be assuming immediately I’m sorry. That’s batshit