• We are currently rolling out incremental alterations to the forum. Don't freak! You aren't going crazy.

Game Elden Ring Mafia

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
It’s just something that stood out :draper
No I get that they kinda contradict each other, but alco said he never even checked the site until Odo posted about the game starting on discord, which does indeed mean that if lethal did the same then he wouldn’t have had chance to familiarise himself with his team anyway. It’s obv all hypothetical and actually just strengthened my original point anyway
 

Lethal

T.B.A
Yes, my perception of you is that you’re quite fearful of entering the thread when you’re scum, and usually like to engage with your team beforehand. Is that wrong?

Well yeah, that's partially right. I'd see who my team is, then play from there.

Although tbf this game started at like 8pm my time which is perfect cos I wasn't waking up to heaps of posts. Always better to be playing live than catch up

No I get that they kinda contradict each other, but alco said he never even checked the site until Odo posted about the game starting on discord, which does indeed mean that if lethal did the same then he wouldn’t have had chance to familiarise himself with his team anyway. It’s obv all hypothetical and actually just strengthened my original point anyway

Yeah I came over when he put the tag out
 

Evans

Acclaimed
No I get that they kinda contradict each other, but alco said he never even checked the site until Odo posted about the game starting on discord, which does indeed mean that if lethal did the same then he wouldn’t have had chance to familiarise himself with his team anyway. It’s obv all hypothetical and actually just strengthened my original point anyway

I get the logic, but I’d be quick to discount it being alignment indicative at all. PMs went out last night. Chats could have been made last night too. Lethals also confirmed to be watching WK which started at 8am UK time which also doesn’t mean anything alignment wise but creates plenty of opportunity for team familiarisation.
 

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
I get the logic, but I’d be quick to discount it being alignment indicative at all. PMs went out last night. Chats could have been made last night too. Lethals also confirmed to be watching WK which started at 8am UK time which also doesn’t mean anything alignment wise but creates plenty of opportunity for team familiarisation.
Ya hence the reason the town read is soft because the PMs being sent out last night muddies things a bit. If they’d been sent this morning and the game started and he was here then I’d just be boldly reading him town tbh

that said him contradicting my stance and offering alternative explanations just makes me think he is town anyway if I’m honest. I think he’d just be relieved and gratefully accept the read if he was scum lol, especially when he just got bodied in xmas mafia
 

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
That said it’s been a while since we played together but I remember this kind of thing being something you’d latch onto when you’re town and the whole line of questioning felt pretty natural to me so I am leaning you as town too
 

Evans

Acclaimed
Ya hence the reason the town read is soft because the PMs being sent out last night muddies things a bit. If they’d been sent this morning and the game started and he was here then I’d just be boldly reading him town tbh

that said him contradicting my stance and offering alternative explanations just makes me think he is town anyway if I’m honest. I think he’d just be relieved and gratefully accept the read if he was scum lol, especially when he just got bodied in xmas mafia

See, I agree with all of this. Especially that second paragraph. The bold bit, reads to me what he’s done thus far in the thread.

He basically parroted the “better to be live than catching up” and agreed with statement that he joined with the tag.

I haven’t seen anything any of the arrogant town Lethal who bum rushes Day 1 start. But I haven’t played with him in forever so this might not be a thing anymore
 

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
Does anybody with more theme knowledge have any theories as to what the mafia alignment might be out of interest?
 

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
See, I agree with all of this. Especially that second paragraph. The bold bit, reads to me what he’s done thus far in the thread.

He basically parroted the “better to be live than catching up” and agreed with statement that he joined with the tag.

I haven’t seen anything any of the arrogant town Lethal who bum rushes Day 1 start. But I haven’t played with him in forever so this might not be a thing anymore
Eh he seemed to take some issue with me asserting that he’s fearful as scum and he also offered the explanation that the game started at a good time for him which is why he was here straight away. I haven’t seen him start that way for quite some time tbh, and he usually doesn’t get involved in the game until a bit later on when there is more meat to get involved in and use to target people

I’d also say none of his usual easy targets are in this game which could affect it. Let’s see how he goes when Ekko and tpein get here :hestonpls
 

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
Tbh this exercise was largely to get the game moving forward with some discussion anyway. I do think lethal is town but he’s not somebody I’d usually put this much effort into figuring out as it usually comes pretty easily as the game progresses lmao. I liked your reaction and I thought Alco’s reaction to it was ok as well. Nothing has really pinged me so far actually so I’m kinda just stood here with my dick in my hand at this point

arp’s role playing also somewhat strikes me as townie for someone that is inexperienced and not something I’d expect a newb to do after drawing scum when they probably don’t have much thought out yet in the way of fake claims
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
He basically parroted the “better to be live than catching up” and agreed with statement that he joined with the tag.
For further context, the tag didn't work for me, and I suspect it's either because Xenforo often has a limit of the amount of users that can be tagged with a notification sent per post or the tags just didn't work. If yours worked, then I'm pretty confused. I note this, because he would have had to dig out the thread specifically, and so would have to have been aware the game started before just checking the site at random and seeing it.
 

Evans

Acclaimed
For further context, the tag didn't work for me, and I suspect it's either because Xenforo often has a limit of the amount of users that can be tagged with a notification sent per post or the tags just didn't work. If yours worked, then I'm pretty confused. I note this, because he would have had to dig out the thread specifically, and so would have to have been aware the game started before just checking the site at random and seeing it.

It’s in reference to a tag on a Discord server we’re all in saying the game was live fwiw
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
...oh. Well that makes sense.

Evans, where exactly are you are with regards to Lethal currently? Because reading your posts, I get the impression that you're comfortably scum reading them, and yet I can see two separate occasions where, if I were to be a tad uncharitable, I could interpret as you giving yourself some wiggle room re Lethal.
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
...oh. Well that makes sense.

Evans, where exactly are you at, with regards to Lethal currently? Because reading your posts, I get the impression that you're comfortably scum reading them, and yet I can see two separate occasions where, if I were to be a tad uncharitable, I could interpret as you giving yourself some wiggle room re Lethal.
 
Back
Top