Game Elden Ring Mafia

[Doddsy]

who do u suggest we vote instead?

can u give me ur top 4 scum reads? we can maybe cross match

With limited understanding of the specifics of play today, from what I'm gathering is we've had 3 investigation claims, tracker/watched/gunsmith right? Chances of all 3 being town is near non existent. Of the 3 I buy Alco the most, probably Dalton the least. So I'd pop him on there.

Rugrat is harder to judge becasue of his play style but I'd be pretty happy lynching him off at this point.

Gets harder at this point. I think Big Man has looked better as he has started to play more, but I thought his posts earlier were non intrusive by design. He was also soft defending Aurelian early if I remember right. I think he has also claimed but from your list but I'm not certain of the details of the role or if that factors in.

Lethal can be GF only, or shenanigans with one of the other roles. Don't think it's worth hedging bets on him, especially as I don't really see the scum side of his play either.

Evans claim I saw was backed up by CP, so that slot also probably town.

BPD was backed up Alco as well - he falls into a similar category as Lethal now, but without Alco's role being confirmed like Ultra's is now. I do buy Alco as town so chances are BPD is just town as well

If anyone I'd probably prefer Dalton, I saw some of the quotes he was leaving for me earlier about how my interactions were faked etc, just seemed like a very forced reason to try and shade me after I gave him a scum lean earlier. If I had to put it into words it's like he used a scum read on him as a crutch to generate content.

 

[Tempest]

I actually disagree, think his reasoning for holstering was fine if he thought he'd be roleblocked (since we knew he'd have the weapon).

we????????????

 

[The X]

he's just good at mafia idk what your problem is with acknowledging it

First of all, not what I'm commenting on. Second of all, that's just so blatantly untrue. Look at my tunnel against him and my wariness of his wolf potential. That's because I think he is a skilled player. Though I disagree with how some of your parrots dive at his crumbs, the fact he has players blindly follow him speaks to his skill as well. Poyser is undoubtedly a threat in any game he plays in.

 

[Emil]

i dont think gramma likes cults lol.

To add, a lot of this Ultra analysis stuff where people are saying "how could you guys lynch Ultra" is massive hindsight heroism imo. we were at a point where we didnt really have better options and needed to get info from a flip.

I prolly would have voted Ultra if i was around tbh

I actually disagree, think his reasoning for holstering was fine if he thought he'd be roleblocked (since we knew he'd have the weapon).

Honestly can't remember, but I do know he's too smart to make such blatant logic jumps as scum (when he's "thinking" about how he posts).

well if he is roleblocked then he confirms me as scum lol. its a win win for him

 

[Doddsy]

Poyser would have drip fed me my ekko claim quote milk by now come on someone

 

[Tempest]

With limited understanding of the specifics of play today, from what I'm gathering is we've had 3 investigation claims, tracker/watched/gunsmith right? Chances of all 3 being town is near non existent. Of the 3 I buy Alco the most, probably Dalton the least. So I'd pop him on there.

Rugrat is harder to judge becasue of his play style but I'd be pretty happy lynching him off at this point.

Gets harder at this point. I think Big Man has looked better as he has started to play more, but I thought his posts earlier were non intrusive by design. He was also soft defending Aurelian early if I remember right. I think he has also claimed but from your list but I'm not certain of the details of the role or if that factors in.

Lethal can be GF only, or shenanigans with one of the other roles. Don't think it's worth hedging bets on him, especially as I don't really see the scum side of his play either.

Evans claim I saw was backed up by CP, so that slot also probably town.

BPD was backed up Alco as well - he falls into a similar category as Lethal now, but without Alco's role being confirmed like Ultra's is now. I do buy Alco as town so chances are BPD is just town as well

If anyone I'd probably prefer Dalton, I saw some of the quotes he was leaving for me earlier about how my interactions were faked etc, just seemed like a very forced reason to try and shade me after I gave him a scum lean earlier. If I had to put it into words it's like he used a scum read on him as a crutch to generate content.

what do you think of alco being a cop for mafia to catch indies? town seems to have a lot of strong roles

 

[Emil]

what do you think of alco being a cop for mafia to catch indies? town seems to have a lot of strong roles

alco or bigman fits this

obviously soul and doddsy didnt claim yet so they fit indie profile too

 

[Doddsy]

what do you think of alco being a cop for mafia to catch indies? town seems to have a lot of strong roles

I agree town have a lot of strong roles but I don't think it's Alco that's hiding among the sheep. He's been pretty solid town since early days for me.

I am still wanting someone to quote me Ekko's claim because chances are he's just SK are sky high, we had mod post confirming that SK was getting power through kills and then Ekko claimed to be an evolving vig.

 

[The X]

of top of my head. might be missing one

im vig
n1 tweet. failed cuz cp?
n2 abstain
n3 tweet

dalton tracker
n1 retro = visited none
n2 abstain
n3 me = visited tweet

u r watcher
n1 abstain
n2 BLD = saw bigman
n3 abstain?

alco gunsmith
n1 poyser = no gun
n2 tweet = no gun
n3 BLD = no gun

big man rune cop and neighborizer
n1 neighborize RDK starting next night
n2 rune cop BLD = no rune + neighborize arp starting next night
n3 ???

retro seraph night
n1 abstain?
n2 protect ultra
n3 abstain / out of shots ?

lethal gift giver
n1 craft weapon
n2 give weapon to RDK. verified as true by RDK
n3 craft another item. didnt say if weapon/armor

cp jailor + costum version of martyr
n1 martyr stops all kills but does not die himself
n2 jail ratchet. possibly stopped the botched janitor kill on ratchet
n3 ???

@Doddsy

 

[SoulKiller]

Something too I noticed I need to catch up to this DP properly but didn't lethal claim that he can craft stuff and gift them to people? Alco being gunsmith is similar to lethal claim no??? Unless I read his role wrong?? ill double check as I read this DP properly but someone do please correct me.

 

[The X]

Or you want Ekko's actual claim post??

 

[Tempest]

I agree town have a lot of strong roles but I don't think it's Alco that's hiding among the sheep. He's been pretty solid town since early days for me.

I am still wanting someone to quote me Ekko's claim because chances are he's just SK are sky high, we had mod post confirming that SK was getting power through kills and then Ekko claimed to be an evolving vig.

that's true but if he is the SK then he needs to kill mafia sooo not a big concern right now

 

[Tempest]

could explain why he wants me to RNG my jail instead of just jailing him outright tho lol

 

[Emil]

With limited understanding of the specifics of play today, from what I'm gathering is we've had 3 investigation claims, tracker/watched/gunsmith right? Chances of all 3 being town is near non existent. Of the 3 I buy Alco the most, probably Dalton the least. So I'd pop him on there.

Rugrat is harder to judge becasue of his play style but I'd be pretty happy lynching him off at this point.

Gets harder at this point. I think Big Man has looked better as he has started to play more, but I thought his posts earlier were non intrusive by design. He was also soft defending Aurelian early if I remember right. I think he has also claimed but from your list but I'm not certain of the details of the role or if that factors in.

Lethal can be GF only, or shenanigans with one of the other roles. Don't think it's worth hedging bets on him, especially as I don't really see the scum side of his play either.

Evans claim I saw was backed up by CP, so that slot also probably town.

BPD was backed up Alco as well - he falls into a similar category as Lethal now, but without Alco's role being confirmed like Ultra's is now. I do buy Alco as town so chances are BPD is just town as well

If anyone I'd probably prefer Dalton, I saw some of the quotes he was leaving for me earlier about how my interactions were faked etc, just seemed like a very forced reason to try and shade me after I gave him a scum lean earlier. If I had to put it into words it's like he used a scum read on him as a crutch to generate content.

i really dislike dalton's direction. man is very contributive, genuine, talking his mind out. i dont know why is he even a scum read

honestly not liking this post. lots of fence sitting only to arrive at what is probably a wrong answer

give me top 4 scums in a list pls

1.
2.
3.
4.

like that

 

[Tempest]

fuck it I'm making some caffeinated chai rn I am about to fall asleep on my keyboard

 

[The X]

Something too I noticed I need to catch up to this DP properly but didn't lethal claim that he can craft stuff and gift them to people? Alco being gunsmith is similar to lethal claim no??? Unless I read his role wrong?? ill double check as I read this DP properly but someone do please correct me.

Lethal is gift maker/giver and Alco is a gunsmith who invests if players have the ability to kill.

 

[Doddsy]

@Doddsy

Was that all, no character or anything?

that's true but if he is the SK then he needs to kill mafia sooo not a big concern right now

Yeah I know I don't especially want to lynch him at this point, but I don't really trust directions he's putting down

 

[Emil]

could explain why he wants me to RNG my jail instead of just jailing him outright tho lol

u can jail me too i appreciate being alive next day

like i said if u do then u just tell mafia to kill someone else

there is rly no scum motive in my request lol

im more than happy to make it alive next day

 

[Tempest]

also kind of interesting that alco hinted a power role on d2 which was picked up on by the entire thread but mafia was cool with him using his role n2 and n3 apparently

 

[The X]

Was that all, no character or anything?

Yeah I know I don't especially want to lynch him at this point, but I don't really trust directions he's putting down

@Ekkologix can you throw this man a bone or something and help him with your claim?