You didn't need to - you received a vest Night 4, which you wouldn't have had you been commuted. Assuming that Craig had jailed Phenom was suboptimal, because you didn't have that as evidence. At the very least, it should have moved Phenom into the immediate PoE.I think we tried to figure out if jail would trump commute and it was a whole mess. I also got fucking SUSSED when I pushed extra hard on Phenom once he said he commuted me.