Game Elden Ring Mafia

Tempest

Leprous Monarch
Strongly disagree with the "tracker and watcher can't both be town" spec btw. That was a standard town role combo for a very long time. Anything can work, just needs to be properly compensated by the rest of the setup.

I was a bit sus of Dalton early because of his play around the Aurelian wagon and reading Ultra's points on him but his later posts while I was alive felt more town. Tiara claiming a "simple watcher" did throw me a bit lol!
 

The X

Marvelous
My dude, I had him town after about 3 posts. I understand I’m more familiar with him than you are, but you’re the one that chose to ignore that testimony and then ignore the testimony of every single other player that was also familiar with him that told you he was town. You then didn’t really take into account how nonsensical his claim would be as scum. Gift giver sure. Gift giver whose items automatically go to whoever hammers or kills him?? Why? Why on Earth would anybody claim that as scum lol. You then ignored him being cleared, and then ignored the godfather flipping that made his clear 100%.

and really, what was the case on him even? He was wrong on everything just like you were but as you’ve said in defence of yourself that doesn’t make a scum. What else did he do badly? Get overly emotional? It’s hardly a strong case at all lol, certainly nowhere near strong enough to ignore the mountain of evidence that pointed to you being wrong

and I don’t really agree with the latter part at all. You can’t blame other people for your own bad reads. Frankly I am BAFFLED that you were town this game as half of the shit you did made literally no sense coming from a townie, but I’ll still always be more mad at myself for getting it wrong and failing to see where the town pov came from. It’s a failing on my part and I’ll try and learn the lesson for future games with you. You clearly take stubbornness to a level that goes far beyond any kind of reasoning. Would have dropped my sus after alco cleared you though!
Didn't you just say it's not my fault if you can't read me? Crazy that you'll defend Lethal this hard but in the same breathe say you were baffled that I was town.
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
I’m not surprised he asked you to check his iso for his reads after you asked him the same question 300 times without ever responding to his answer
i always ask for updated lists based on new development or after someone talks. idk how hard it is to list ur reads live after every 3 pages. townies just need to keep pooling their thoughts on the table. clog the foken thread with it if need be lol

anyway my idea of playing town is clearly different. we will always not agree on this I guess
 

The X

Marvelous
It's just like Xmas game where you started calling me indie for no reason. You're a good player and I think next time we're both town, scum don't stand a chance.
 

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
im not gna say lethal played bad

just he played in a style that I struggle forgiving and letting go

I agree that not everyone needs to play the same. working out with people's different play style is a skill I need to work on still
Yea but you seem to expect everyone to put in a lot of effort to ever clear them as town. That’s just never going to happen lol. Every game has people that don’t do that. You’ve gotta find other ways to take people out of poe or your poe is always gonna be too big
 

Ratchet

Resplendent
Advisor
is it a common convention that commuters are only self target in WS?

ive seen commuters being non self target alot
Commuter tends to be a role that can only self-target. In effect it removes the player from the game for a night. Being targetable is a convention that leans more into the heavy role madness style you're more familiar with.
 

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
is it a common convention that commuters are only self target in WS?

ive seen commuters being non self target alot
I’ve seen a forced commuter once or twice. Wasn’t really the issue tho lol, the issue is he claimed the exact same role as CP just with a different name
 

The X

Marvelous
Like Poyser literally finishing his rant with saying I take stubbornness to a new level. Definitely sounds like he's taking accountability!
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
and obviously we got unlucky with doddsy being bulletproof and BLD having a hater passive and the indies killing town and pushing town

anyway gg. onto the next

had lots of fun with this one
 

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
Didn't you just say it's not my fault if you can't read me? Crazy that you'll defend Lethal this hard but in the same breathe say you were baffled that I was town.
It’s not your fault, it’s mine. I’m saying how I was baffled because (in my opinion) you played shit but I still think it’s my failing for not seeing the town pov from you. You play how you play and the style you play with, it’s totally up to me to learn how to read you
 

The X

Marvelous
It’s not your fault, it’s mine. I’m saying how I was baffled because (in my opinion) you played shit but I still think it’s my failing for not seeing the town pov from you. You play how you play and the style you play with, it’s totally up to me to learn how to read you
I played like shit? Where were you? Blown out N2 because you think claiming indie like you do is a good idea. Not sure why you talk so big.
 
Back
Top