Game Elden Ring Mafia

PHEN0M

GOATN0M
I literally quoted it in dead chat on my catch up and said “oh yeah phenom is scum” and then 5 days later you still weren’t lynched

charlton heston laughing GIF

I had already planned to claim my fake character and Forced Commuter and then i saw the jailkeeper claim and went, yeah i don’t care I can WIFOM out of that. Despite me not eating a lynch, now me wants to slap the shit out of then me cuz boy that was not it.

I personally was a big fan of claiming x-shot and then Ekko going, “CP was non-consecutive, what about you?” “ Oh yeah, most definitely. Was totally fucking with scum I’m the same” and then just going with it.
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
I’ve seen a forced commuter once or twice. Wasn’t really the issue tho lol, the issue is he claimed the exact same role as CP just with a different name
its not rly a different role. in the action processing order apparently commuter is faster. for us, a jailkeeper only roleblocks and protects the target. it does not stop players from visiting the target. a forced commuter stops ALL actions. for WS seems like the roles r the same.

anyway that's all setup spec. ultimately its his gameplay that we judge him based on. he was going to be last day's lynch or the one before it if evans just played townie and pushed phenom instead of claim

the PoE works in magical ways poyser. u cant see it from our PoV because u have outsider spectator mod knowledge

to us the last day was between evans and phenom after BLD defended himself very well he wasn't an option. the way BLD removed himself from being lynched shuda been how evans do it

all we needed is evans to push for phenom. from his PoV he is 10000000000000000% sure it had to be phenom. he did push it at the end but claimed indie in the process which weakened his claim and made it seem he could be a fake claiming scum

lastly before we could discuss, the wagon was hammeredd by TOWN. yes TOWN hammered it. we needed to discuss that we will lose cuz of BPD's passive

if the game was plurality or otherwise we just took the time to think it through we wud arrive at lynching phenom first being more ideal

its easy to speak from outsider PoV. we don't know in the game who is indie or who is mafia. we hunted rugrat as scum and he flipped indie. from his PoV he shuda been able to town his ass off and push the lynch onto doddsy but couldn't. evans failed the same task against phenom.

towning ur ass off when in PoE is an important deciding factor for me. that's all there is to it
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
Commuter tends to be a role that can only self-target. In effect it removes the player from the game for a night. Being targetable is a convention that leans more into the heavy role madness style you're more familiar with.
im more familiar with jailkeeper being strictly roleblock + protect. if X target Y with a jailkeerper, that's what they do. and anybody else can visit Y normally and it wouldn't fail (unless its a kill)

however a forced commuter is a role that completely removes player from the game. nothing can target them. so if X force commutes Y then Y is not in the game for the night and anything targeting them fails.
 

Grammaton

Consigliere
Moderator
The issue is we (WF) use two flavours of jail keeper, whereas you use a jailkeeper (rb +doc) and a force commuter (which is exactly the same as our second jk flavour)

that’s literally all it is
 

The X

Marvelous
I'll let you do the talking then
Yes Craig, I already said that this was a unique game for me and brought out a lot of old energy. I think to define my whole game as being 'stubborn beyond reason' is a pretty unfair judgment. I think i showed numerous times my ability to try and listen as well as explain myself. I was unreasonable with Lethal the first time but then gave him a chance. Unfortunately I didn't like how he played after D4 and couldn't take my blinders off. I had my blinders on with you and it was tough to get out of my tunnel after your claim. But I did eventually and was able to put you in town POE. So do I disagree that I am reasonable beyond doubt? Yeah, I do. In a game like this I think most people can get into pretty good tunnels. But how did you respond to it? Instead of trying to figure me out or work with me, you just called me scum and didn't listen to a single thing I had to say. I think my actions and words showed that I really was trying to work with people and clear up any wrong interpretations about my slot. Maybe it's tough for me to play a game like this right now considering I've been playing games where abilities are little off the wall insane, but sometimes I question roles and abilities too much. You continuously screaming you're confirmed doesn't really help anything, same with Lethal and his at times standoffish attitude. If I'm wrong, I can usually admit that (eventually)!

Now, I hope this is a satisfying reply to you. Obviously my game bothers you, and that's okay! But you honestly don't need to wait until I comment on something Poyser says to jump in at me. I think there are more mature and productive ways to have a conversation. I know that maybe I can be an ass or stubborn, but I'm also playing a game about ego and lying on the Internet; I promise I am very approachable in real life!
 

Lethal

Exceptional
u have much more meta knowledge on him than us, for instance, we have never seen town lethal lol. he has always been scum where we play

we were able to identify say retro as town because we have seen town retro play. we struggled with lethal and we tried over multiple times to work with him

things like "check my iso for my reads" and "the only thing clearing you is being vig" . and foken "yeah I am back on the table" is really not stuff I am capable of letting go easily. maybe you can. I probably will not be able to.
You asked 500 questions, refuse to see the answer, then ask it another 300 times. Insufferable. 2000 posts that flood the thread and allow scum to blend in. Flat out arrogance to dismiss a reads list built by someone (fwiw I had phenom & Evans correct). You were so preoccupied with buddying up to dragon that you clouded your own game. You literally played scum with me a month ago.
 

Lethal

Exceptional
im more familiar with jailkeeper being strictly roleblock + protect. if X target Y with a jailkeerper, that's what they do. and anybody else can visit Y normally and it wouldn't fail (unless its a kill)

however a forced commuter is a role that completely removes player from the game. nothing can target them. so if X force commutes Y then Y is not in the game for the night and anything targeting them fails.
You’ve played plenty of WS games with jailkeeper so keep bullshitting.

And you’ve seen my town game plenty on WS too. Lol.
 

Ultra

THE BEAR
Advisor
Like I said in dead chat, I dunno how you can talk shit about misreading Lethal when most of town misread me. It naturally gets confusing when someone's meta tells coincide with general common scum tells
 

Lethal

Exceptional
Like I said in dead chat, I dunno how you can talk shit about misreading Lethal when most of town misread me. It naturally gets confusing when someone's meta tells coincide with general common scum tells
Im still frustrated I was wrong on you. Dented my confidence
 

T-Pein™

The Nexus
Pronouns
They/Them
Like I said in dead chat, I dunno how you can talk shit about misreading Lethal when most of town misread me. It naturally gets confusing when someone's meta tells coincide with general common scum tells

No ultra kun.
It was ok to lynch you.
Lynching lethal bad tho.
Sussing the scumiest player bad.
 

T-Pein™

The Nexus
Pronouns
They/Them
Yes Craig, I already said that this was a unique game for me and brought out a lot of old energy. I think to define my whole game as being 'stubborn beyond reason' is a pretty unfair judgment. I think i showed numerous times my ability to try and listen as well as explain myself. I was unreasonable with Lethal the first time but then gave him a chance. Unfortunately I didn't like how he played after D4 and couldn't take my blinders off. I had my blinders on with you and it was tough to get out of my tunnel after your claim. But I did eventually and was able to put you in town POE. So do I disagree that I am reasonable beyond doubt? Yeah, I do. In a game like this I think most people can get into pretty good tunnels. But how did you respond to it? Instead of trying to figure me out or work with me, you just called me scum and didn't listen to a single thing I had to say. I think my actions and words showed that I really was trying to work with people and clear up any wrong interpretations about my slot. Maybe it's tough for me to play a game like this right now considering I've been playing games where abilities are little off the wall insane, but sometimes I question roles and abilities too much. You continuously screaming you're confirmed doesn't really help anything, same with Lethal and his at times standoffish attitude. If I'm wrong, I can usually admit that (eventually)!

Now, I hope this is a satisfying reply to you. Obviously my game bothers you, and that's okay! But you honestly don't need to wait until I comment on something Poyser says to jump in at me. I think there are more mature and productive ways to have a conversation. I know that maybe I can be an ass or stubborn, but I'm also playing a game about ego and lying on the Internet; I promise I am very approachable in real life!

Your CP tunnel was always silly.
Specially since he literally stopped all kills...
Lethal one was fine tho.
 

Dr. Watson

‣ ↻
Administrator
So.

One thing I really want to discuss here is the use of "Y and X have done fake excuses before."

Because I really, really feel for Lethal here. I know it's part of the game but it's an angle I've never liked, which you all saw with what also occurred in the Aurelian lynch.

And I understand it's entirely up to the player to read/believe the sincerity behind statements like these, but frustration at the game and others is real.

I'm just not sure how to limit that frustration when players are being pressed
 
Back
Top