• We are currently rolling out incremental alterations to the forum. Don't freak! You aren't going crazy.

Monster Hunter World Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Emil

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
Imposter said:
Go ahead and explain the town read.
If you were paying attention, you'd see I've currently got an alternative too. Perhaps you'd care to comment on Melkor?
It is absolutely pointless to flavour hunt and speculate on characters in a game like this. Sure do it for fun but no use looking any further than that. Your question re the Miller was along the same lines. Not sure why you wouldn't just ask CP for his character if you thought it mattered
I'll highlight the important bits for you
Click to expand...
leaning town on melkor
what discussion about him did u open?

miller flavor needs to add up, unless u think he is a mafia who is fake claiming miller and has a miller fake claim provided to him by gram it should add up to a role that fits miller... or unless u think he has a town role that does not fit miller but is somewhow miller. is that the point u r making?
 
Hans Tweetenberg

Hans Tweetenberg

Exceptional
Ekkologix said:
the line of thought itself is likely going to lead us at exactly nowhere flavorwise but u could glean alignment from him or people reacting to it imo. its better to keep it going for a bit and see where it goes rather than cut it short
Click to expand...
Incidentally you continuing to tell us that discussion over meaningless things may tell us something about peoples alignments is telling me something about your alignment
 
Emil

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
Ultra said:
Even if you could glean information from useless discussion, it stands to reason you could gain more from not useless discussion so I'm not really seeing your point here.

Especially since Imposter was just making a neutral observation and didn't even really shade RAEM for it.
Click to expand...
i think its bad to cut it short. least he could do is wait and see how much time does RAEM invest in it. if RAEM spent more time on it, even while the thread is active, then it'd be poorly received

but RAEM discussing flavor in page 4 in a semi dead thread is perfectly fine with me and shud not be interrupted imo
 
Ultra

Ultra

THE BEAR
Moderator
Mafia Beast
Ekkologix said:
i think its bad to cut it short. least he could do is wait and see how much time does RAEM invest in it. if RAEM spent more time on it, even while the thread is active, then it'd be poorly received

but RAEM discussing flavor in page 4 in a semi dead thread is perfectly fine with me and shud not be interrupted imo
Click to expand...

Ok.

Ignore any posts I have made so far.

I'm going to commit the rest of today to discussing big tits - I want you to produce a read from that
 
Emil

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
Ultra said:
Ok.

Ignore any posts I have made so far.

I'm going to commit the rest of today to discussing big tits - I want you to produce a read from that
Click to expand...
if u do that while the thread is actively engaging in something meaningful it'll read scummy to me. it'll be you cosplaying midnight. is there any point to this btw?
 
Ultra

Ultra

THE BEAR
Moderator
Mafia Beast
Imposter said:
Go ahead and explain the town read.
If you were paying attention, you'd see I've currently got an alternative too. Perhaps you'd care to comment on Melkor?
It is absolutely pointless to flavour hunt and speculate on characters in a game like this. Sure do it for fun but no use looking any further than that. Your question re the Miller was along the same lines. Not sure why you wouldn't just ask CP for his character if you thought it mattered
I'll highlight the important bits for you
Click to expand...

Actually Imposter I do have a question - are you implying you did scum read RAEM here? Because I didn't get that from your post
 
Imposter

Imposter

Illustrious
Ekkologix said:
leaning town on melkor
what discussion about him did u open?

miller flavor needs to add up, unless u think he is a mafia who is fake claiming miller and has a miller fake claim provided to him by gram it should add up to a role that fits miller... or unless u think he has a town role that does not fit miller but is somewhow miller. is that the point u r making?
Click to expand...
Why is that?
I mean I presented an alternative with the wagon that was going on him. People could prod into that if they like or get reads on those voting him.
What do you make of him using meta reasoning to suggest it's NAI for you to say you're switching your game up? Is this something you've done before/often?
Miller flavour doesn't need to add up when the OP specifically says he's gonna throw curveballs in to trip us up and punish that kind of play. FWIW I still think it might do but I won't be surprised if it doesn't and frankly it's irrelevant either way.
I don't think he gave scum a miller fake no.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top