Lord Melkor
Exceptional
My impressions so far
Town - Melkor, Xadlin
Scum - Sworder, Lethal, Rem, one of the top poster duo
And now sayonara
Interesting.
What makes you town read Xadlin.
Any opinions on Hime and T-Pein, as they are wagons today?
Monster Hunter World Mafia - Game Thread
- Thread starter Grammaton
- Start date
- Status
Interesting.
What makes you town read Xadlin.
Any opinions on Hime and T-Pein, as they are wagons today?
ur case on me is opportunistic af??
everyone going along with it is lame
honestly this feels similar to last game where u offered up lame reasons to push a lynch on me
that game was a mega huge outlier
i dont play like that as scum or town normally and i even stated that post-game
u had access to scum chats and everything after the game, i got myself modblocked, didnt send in a single action, nor did i even know my own abilities that game
last game u said u had respect for my play, i take offense if u think bleach is a reliable source for my meta
Vote lynch Ultra
Funny enough, this is exactly how you responded when I pushed you as well!
Ok first 10 pages read so I am now a whole 1/4 of the way through the thread!!! Hype!! Here are my notes so far
- Flower votes ultra only after he said he was weirded out that she didnt kek. Also made a weird post about being wary of magic but being thankful raisin is in game... raisin never played game before
- Like RAEM because he voted flower when I was thinking she was SUS
- Tweet oddly defensive of flower asking for reasons for votes - but voted Melkor after Ultra without any prompting and didnt seem interested in explanation. Also tries a bit too hard to be aggro to ultra, feels forced. Also weird post like "hey somebody actually engaging me" despite ultra trying to engage multiple times. also seems eager to explain his vote on melkor, but could have just offered it himself without being asked...
Very interested in flower, as asked Ultra to elaborate on town read as well by asking if it was meta. These guys are probably not aligned at the very least, too awkward.
- Think the reasons on RAEM are crap. Him asking who voted him instead of why they voted after he'd only made 1 post makes perfect sense. Trying to twist it into something scummy is pretty sus tbh. This is aimed at Tweet and Ultra
- In fact, this tweet/ultra interaction reminds me a bit of mine and ultra's interactions early last game. Tweet is just not as good at it as me, but Ultra seems to be trying his best to shade without going anywhere with it. I'm used to Ultra having sharper teeth as town
- Ekko seems kinda awkward but it makes me think he might be town. Be a bit weird to go out of your way to change your meta as scum when your regular meta is such a big benefit as scum, and changing it is just gonna draw attention kek. That said will have to see how he progresses from here
- Also think RAEM looks decent enough with people trying to sus him for flavour spec, doesn't really back down
- Imposter seems a bit defensive to Ekko
- Ultra vote on Ekko just seems lazy and weak to me. Also joined tweet which is midly strange after their interaction. Tweet also backing up the weak stuff on ekko. They're both playing as though they've never played with Ekko or something
- WRT Ekko, I also think his defence of RAEM is similar to how he defended me from my early game sus last game too, which at least shows his thought process is treading the same lines as when he was town
- Cant really make my mind up about Imposter. He's posting and he's not pinging me but nothing is really standing out to me in terms of liking it either. I guess I like him questioning Melkor that said Ekko changing his game up is NAI, and throwing his vote there. That's something I guess
- Ultra talking pure shite and making no good points whatsoever to Ekko wrt flavour discussion lol. He's arguing against straw men and it's a bad look. Then again I think he was way more focused in our last game and not posting so much shite early on, so maybe it's just that his town game doesnt really jive with me. Wouldn't exactly be the first time i just pure hate his posts kek
TOWN
CP cuz miller
RAEM early impression good and like him more the more i read
Ekko kinda
SLIGHTLY TOWNIER THAN NULL
Imposter
SUS
Tweet
Flower (Not aligned with tweet tho)
MINOR SUS
Ultra
- Flower votes ultra only after he said he was weirded out that she didnt kek. Also made a weird post about being wary of magic but being thankful raisin is in game... raisin never played game before
- Like RAEM because he voted flower when I was thinking she was SUS
- Tweet oddly defensive of flower asking for reasons for votes - but voted Melkor after Ultra without any prompting and didnt seem interested in explanation. Also tries a bit too hard to be aggro to ultra, feels forced. Also weird post like "hey somebody actually engaging me" despite ultra trying to engage multiple times. also seems eager to explain his vote on melkor, but could have just offered it himself without being asked...
Very interested in flower, as asked Ultra to elaborate on town read as well by asking if it was meta. These guys are probably not aligned at the very least, too awkward.
- Think the reasons on RAEM are crap. Him asking who voted him instead of why they voted after he'd only made 1 post makes perfect sense. Trying to twist it into something scummy is pretty sus tbh. This is aimed at Tweet and Ultra
- In fact, this tweet/ultra interaction reminds me a bit of mine and ultra's interactions early last game. Tweet is just not as good at it as me, but Ultra seems to be trying his best to shade without going anywhere with it. I'm used to Ultra having sharper teeth as town
- Ekko seems kinda awkward but it makes me think he might be town. Be a bit weird to go out of your way to change your meta as scum when your regular meta is such a big benefit as scum, and changing it is just gonna draw attention kek. That said will have to see how he progresses from here
- Also think RAEM looks decent enough with people trying to sus him for flavour spec, doesn't really back down
- Imposter seems a bit defensive to Ekko
- Ultra vote on Ekko just seems lazy and weak to me. Also joined tweet which is midly strange after their interaction. Tweet also backing up the weak stuff on ekko. They're both playing as though they've never played with Ekko or something
- WRT Ekko, I also think his defence of RAEM is similar to how he defended me from my early game sus last game too, which at least shows his thought process is treading the same lines as when he was town
- Cant really make my mind up about Imposter. He's posting and he's not pinging me but nothing is really standing out to me in terms of liking it either. I guess I like him questioning Melkor that said Ekko changing his game up is NAI, and throwing his vote there. That's something I guess
- Ultra talking pure shite and making no good points whatsoever to Ekko wrt flavour discussion lol. He's arguing against straw men and it's a bad look. Then again I think he was way more focused in our last game and not posting so much shite early on, so maybe it's just that his town game doesnt really jive with me. Wouldn't exactly be the first time i just pure hate his posts kek
TOWN
CP cuz miller
RAEM early impression good and like him more the more i read
Ekko kinda
SLIGHTLY TOWNIER THAN NULL
Imposter
SUS
Tweet
Flower (Not aligned with tweet tho)
MINOR SUS
Ultra
I'm not giving her any medals for her reads mind you. I actually find it quite annoying that she hands them out like candy.
Can you bring up the post in question?
seems like a town post but I dont have the contect of the last 30 pages
Lord Melkor
Exceptional
Caught up.
I am liking Ultra, Magic, Natalija right now the most.
Hime looks a bit better with her recent posts, not sure if her scum self would be bold enough to vote Ultra at this stage.
I would be fine with Sworder, Lethal or T-Pein lynch right now.
Though there is not much resistance to T-Pein lynch?
Change Vote Lynch Sworder
I am liking Ultra, Magic, Natalija right now the most.
Hime looks a bit better with her recent posts, not sure if her scum self would be bold enough to vote Ultra at this stage.
I would be fine with Sworder, Lethal or T-Pein lynch right now.
Though there is not much resistance to T-Pein lynch?
Change Vote Lynch Sworder
Ok kinda weird that you make this point against Ekko when it applies to about 50% of Tweet's posts also at the point this was posted lmao
Any reason tweet has been ignored for you?
What dont you like about those three?
I'm actually surprised you picked up what I wasn't jiving with about Tweet earlier...and then proceed to shade us both. lol
For the record I'm willing to chalk up some of his reaction here to Tweet just thinking I'm an asshole. Later in the thread he brings up at random that time I mislynched him. His reaction was a bit jarring, but it was mostly weird, I'm hesitant to call it scummy and as far as his wider play goes haven't taken any real issue with it
I don't like you trying to spin this as a partner interaction, feels lazy, and you can take off sny credibility you would otherwise be forced to give me by conceding points against tweets early game behavior
Lord Melkor
Exceptional
T-Pein does not seem to be doing any gamesolving.
From Sworder I recall only comment on the miller claim.
Lethal is acting weird, I remember he was my scummate and acted similar once. I do not remember how Lethal usually plays as town. People say you can read him well?
Riveting. Poyser why did you even throw Imposter on your list here lol
Lord Melkor
Exceptional
Yes, I also noted Tweet was defensive of Flower in first pages, though this not make sense in case there were partners to me.
You do not start the game by openly defending your scumbuddy, distancing is usual approach.
You do not start the game by openly defending your scumbuddy, distancing is usual approach.
Yeah I can see how that comes across as a pocket or something, but she has an established precedent for the "town leader" archetype, will literally give players like Magic/Ratchet free town reads and ride his coat tails all game, so this tracks. She can't go two seconds without looking for a player to sheep
Not sure what point you're trying to make here?
Tweet is my top sus, and I do think your interaction reminds me a bit of ours, because you didn't show any teeth towards him whatsoever despite clearly having a problem with his play. Not something I'm used to you doing as town.
The last point you make is particularly bad. What are you accusing me of? You seem worried that I won't give you any credibility if Tweet flips scum, yet you paint that as scummy rather than a misread on my part. But that doesn't jive unless you're already accusing me of bussing tweet and trying to set you up afterwards?
i noticed he was posting a lot and i didnt have an opinion on him at all so i wanted to try and force myself to think about it kek
It's actually precisely what she did in the game I linked kek
Mind you I haven't evaluated her catch up
yes i did say they're unlikely to be aligned as its too awkward.
do you read any of them scum independently of that?
Alco
Distinguished
I don't know, man, you've been asked for reads and twice you've joked about reading back before backtracking. Maybe change that up a little bit.
its d1.
literally just lynching w/e
What you want me to do.
not like they have any case or anything against me.
- Status