• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked My Hero Academia Mafia Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
You just gave me like 3 different answers I'm calling in @Grammaton
I’m fuzzy on the details I just remember there was a disagreement about this recently that I think involved me and gram disagreeing with how I handled something. It might have been my game or it may have been me giving advice to someone else lol. I just can’t remember whether or not magic gave his take on it

I think it’s a debatable thing tho, which is why it’s a shame he doesn’t have his action resolution posted
 
I only need to explain a desperado once you've died, or we have a scum death. In the former case I would be conceding my argument, and probably also in the latter.
 
Because the SK can get caught outright under the right circumstances by Jailer so why not lop his head off.

@Ratchet Don't think we can entertain the SK having a block can we? From a flavor standpoint.
 
Thing is the SK doesn't know that so I still find it a bit puzzling, unless maybe he can't be blocked or something
Yeah maybe, I think if Rugrat is town it pretty much has to be Gad or Dofla. Probably Gad, because that would explain Mango's result. Agreed?
 
I don't really need to because until it is evidenced, it isn't proven to exist. It being a night action further makes this more difficult, because you would need to declare a target and could claim that the jail affected it in some way.
Well no this is a poor answer. If I’m scum then obviously it doesn’t exist lol

But I’m claiming another killing role for ??? Reasons when we’ve just had 2 flip and another multi one claimed

Not only a killing role but one that would kill myself. So obv if I’m scum I’m doing this knowing I can never prove it

But I’m also doing it knowing that there’s seventeen killing roles already proven to be in the game
 
Because the SK can get caught outright under the right circumstances by Jailer so why not lop his head off.

@Ratchet Don't think we can entertain the SK having a block can we? From a flavor standpoint.
I dunno, I dropped the manga years ago and only have vague guesses as to who it could be anyway.

FTR I think on the basis of kill choice, a PoE of Gad/Poyser makes a bit more sense to me than Poyser/Rugrat. I concede that Rugrat might be the most informative flip though.
 
I dunno, I dropped the manga years ago and only have vague guesses as to who it could be anyway.

FTR I think on the basis of kill choice, a PoE of Gad/Poyser makes a bit more sense to me than Poyser/Rugrat. I concede that Rugrat might be the most informative flip though.

Default answer is Stain like 99% of the time, he can paralyze people by tasting their blood
 
The most logical conclusion to me is nibel redirected to the tracker. If they do have a redirect, that’s the obvious play
 
But I’m claiming another killing role for ??? Reasons when we’ve just had 2 flip and another multi one claimed
Not only a killing role but one that would kill myself. So obv if I’m scum I’m doing this knowing I can never prove it
WIFOM - by making this argument you prove why you would do it. As scum, you're not likely to be able to prove your role at this stage, so a role that buys you an extra night would be worthwhile. Realistically, we also need to consider that as scum, your chances of winning aren't very high anyway, it basically boils down to delaying your death as long as possible and hope that between you and the SK, you can whittle down town enough to make a game of it. Even making it to F6 would be a big achievement at this stage.

Given the above, you don't need to have a clear cut path to victory with your claim. It doesn't even need to be provable. Just needs to delay long enough for you to eliminate the players that are the biggest threat to your wincon, and then try to convince the ones that are left as much as you can.
 
WIFOM - by making this argument you prove why you would do it. As scum, you're not likely to be able to prove your role at this stage, so a role that buys you an extra night would be worthwhile. Realistically, we also need to consider that as scum, your chances of winning aren't very high anyway, it basically boils down to delaying your death as long as possible and hope that between you and the SK, you can whittle down town enough to make a game of it. Even making it to F6 would be a big achievement at this stage.

Given the above, you don't need to have a clear cut path to victory with your claim. It doesn't even need to be provable. Just needs to delay long enough for you to eliminate the players that are the biggest threat to your wincon, and then try to convince the ones that are left as much as you can.
This is the biggest load of dreck I’ve ever seen
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top