Game Ranked My Hero Academia Mafia Thread

[Poyser]

Bruh you just admitted you can't explain Gad this game, why defend him?

Because if I can’t explain why someone would do the things they’re doing as scum then I tend to default to thinking they’re more likely to be town (or Indy I gusss which is what you’re pushing but I’m not sure I buy)

 

[DoflaMihawk]

Because if I can’t explain why someone would do the things they’re doing as scum then I tend to default to thinking they’re more likely to be town (or Indy I gusss which is what you’re pushing but I’m not sure I buy)

If I'm wrong then feel free to desperado me (since I'll survive anyway)

 

[Ratchet]

If I target gad and he’s town then he wouldn’t die but fair enough

Well, either way. To be honest, for the sake of clarity it's probably better if you commit to one direction. The issue of course is the possibility of a false clear, if the Indie is Iron they would survive your kill and thus not die. So I don't think there is really all that much use out of your role other than proving you're town here, it is important that you don't overlap with a jailer.

@Chairman Nibel Make sure you jail Dofla, and Bachi. Do not jail Poyser or Gad.

That pretty much deals with that.

 

[Ratchet]

Well he’d have just been told that his kill was a strongman, so if he held then it shouldn’t be because he fears being jailed

I remind you that this is Fang.

 

[Poyser]

why are you telling him to jail dofla

nibel should just not use his role tonight, or use it to protect ultra or you. i dont think jailing dofla makes a lot of sense

 

[Poyser]

I remind you that this is Fang.

this is fair

 

[Ratchet]

Then from there, if Poyser survives you lynch him, otherwise lynch between Gad/Dofla. Gram would be next after those actually, but given his claim, could be overlooked for the jail tonight.

 

[Ratchet]

why are you telling him to jail dofla

nibel should just not use his role tonight, or use it to protect ultra or you. i dont think jailing dofla makes a lot of sense

He's going to try and block kills.

 

[Poyser]

tbh i thought rugrats angles in his convo to me before were kinda slimy and in bad faith so im more happy voting there now than i was

i still cant figure out why he'd shoot fang really, but im not gonna hang my hat on that with whats been happening

 

[Poyser]

He's going to try and block kills.

id rather he didnt jail dofla specifically tho. im most likely to go there tonight, tho if rugrat does flip sk i will probably take your advice and go gad

i def want dofla as an option though

 

[Poyser]

that said, directing nibel seems like a pointless exercise. dont think ive seen him listen once, either this game or when he was the vig

 

[Rugrat]

Yeah, but the SK is pretty much always bp... Come on mate lol

I didn’t think about this, fair point

 

[Rugrat]

tbh i thought rugrats angles in his convo to me before were kinda slimy and in bad faith so im more happy voting there now than i was

i still cant figure out why he'd shoot fang really, but im not gonna hang my hat on that with whats been happening

What was in bad faith? That I thought all PGO’s were unlimited???

Why on earth would I make that up?

 

[DoflaMihawk]

Still haven't heard an explanation as to why the SK would kill the No.1 SK suspect

 

[Rugrat]

Tbh I still think PGO’s are basically always unlimited actually, I stick by that.

 

[Ratchet]

id rather he didnt jail dofla specifically tho. im most likely to go there tonight, tho if rugrat does flip sk i will probably take your advice and go gad

i def want dofla as an option though

If you are shooting Dofla, Nibel must jail Gad, or vice versa. Take that up with him - "my target was jailed" isn't going to be a satisfactory explanation as to why you're not dead.

 

[Rugrat]

Never seen a PGO role where it’s “the first role that targets you does” or “one shot PGO”

At any rate if this was a controversial attempt to pull the wool over eyes, I’d just ask Magic (or claim to, if we think the claim is fake)

 

[Rugrat]

tbh i thought rugrats angles in his convo to me before were kinda slimy and in bad faith so im more happy voting there now than i was

i still cant figure out why he'd shoot fang really, but im not gonna hang my hat on that with whats been happening

So because mafia suck, it reconciles that I would make the dumbest kill ever?

 

[Rugrat]

Is there any reason not to keep me alive until N5, assigning me a target and just lynching me on D6 if the game is still on?

 

[Ratchet]

Is there any reason not to keep me alive until N5, assigning me a target and just lynching me on D6 if the game is still on?

What do you think?