Game Ranked My Hero Academia Mafia Thread

[Flower]

vote lynch gad



Dayphase has begun. Ultra has been exposed. He was:

Spoiler: Spoiler

Vote Lynch Gad

seems pretty clear cut then

vote gad

Open to suggestions here on who to shoot. Probably depends on his flip but Im thinking if he flips town/SK then I'd likely shoot Dofla, and if he flips mafia then maybe cubey or bachi?

Dofla: Gad.
Nibel: Gad.
Poyser: Gad.

Gad: 3.

With 9 alive it's 5 to lynch.

 

[Poyser]

still get paranoid about nibel but i pretty much have to rule that out based on rolespec alone

 

[Ratchet]

Hi. Guys, it's possible I made an error. I said I jailed Dofla during night 3 but it was Gad. Also last night I jailed Mango and Gad.

Yeah that basically shores that up. Why didn't you jail Dofla?

 

[Poyser]

then again wasnt mango blocked the other night when only one kill was missing? probably means it cant be both mango and gad

 

[Poyser]

nvm im mistaken. he was blocked (or so he says) but i was thinking there was 2 kills when both gad and mango were jailed which isnt correct. it was probably moved from gad to mango so they could still both be the remaining scum

 

[Poyser]

so yeah

if sk then ill shoot dofla
if anything else then ill shoot mango

and if nibel jails my target and i die anyway then whatever lol, doubt it makes a difference either way

 

[Poyser]

Just vote ratchet, let’s get the game done

 

[Ratchet]

guess ill just shoot mango unless gad flips sk? could easily see SK with a tracking perk tbf and i have scum read him most of the game, just cleared him based on the scum rolecop flipping

if gad flips sk, ill shoot dofla

Mango is a claimed tracker with a rolewatcher already flipped, given that town already have limited investigation ability (alternating hider, one shot cop in Fang's role, your desperado, maybe hime's role) a tracker really should be present. Mango should basically never be shot. If Gad doesn't flip SK, you'd need to be shooting Dofla anyway, that's where your shot should be irrespective of Gad's flip.

 

[Ratchet]

I'd rather we don't speedlynch, at minimum everyone should be able to offer their input. With the modkill we are basically at par if there are 2 scum left, would like us to slow it down a tad.

 

[Poyser]

Mango is a claimed tracker with a rolewatcher already flipped, given that town already have limited investigation ability (alternating hider, one shot cop in Fang's role, your desperado, maybe hime's role) a tracker really should be present. Mango should basically never be shot. If Gad doesn't flip SK, you'd need to be shooting Dofla anyway, that's where your shot should be irrespective of Gad's flip.

Its not limited investigation lol. 3 shot hider, 1 shot cop (which could be upgraded to go through investigation immunity), desperado, FOUR SHOT watcher

thats a fuck tonne of investigation

 

[Ratchet]

Its not limited investigation lol. 3 shot hider, 1 shot cop (which could be upgraded to go through investigation immunity), desperado, FOUR SHOT watcher

thats a fuck tonne of investigation

I did forget about the watcher, but it should be noted that the hider was odd night only - he would need 5 nights to get all 3 shots off. But yes, with the watcher my point doesn't really hold much water there.

I think you should be shooting Dofla either way though, if Gad isn't SK he's the other slot that was jailed when we can assume a kill had failed.

 

[Poyser]

if anyone had limited investigation, it was mafia. they could only rolecop people that specifically targeted cp... on even nights

 

[Poyser]

I did forget about the watcher, but it should be noted that the hider was odd night only - he would need 5 nights to get all 3 shots off. But yes, with the watcher my point doesn't really hold much water there.

I think you should be shooting Dofla either way though, if Gad isn't SK he's the other slot that was jailed when we can assume a kill had failed.

thing is, dofla shooting hime is a stretch. i could see it if hes mafia basically because its a team game and hes gotta set up the game to win etc etc

as SK hes basically just playing for himself, so do you really think he'd shoot hime there? i mean i dont know dofla well enough so maybe you'll have more insight there than me, but feels like a no

 

[Poyser]

im not saying mango is mafia, there's almost no way that is the case. there's no reason at all he couldnt be sk tho

he was blocked twice, and both of those nights had a missing kill
his predecessor didnt submit N1, and only 1 kill
he was not blocked on N2, and there were 3 kills

u do the math

 

[Poyser]

I did forget about the watcher, but it should be noted that the hider was odd night only - he would need 5 nights to get all 3 shots off. But yes, with the watcher my point doesn't really hold much water there.

I think you should be shooting Dofla either way though, if Gad isn't SK he's the other slot that was jailed when we can assume a kill had failed.

dofla was never targeted for a jail remember, nibel just corrected himself

not that there was any ever proof nibel wasnt messed with that night anyway

 

[Ratchet]

thing is, dofla shooting hime is a stretch. i could see it if hes mafia basically because its a team game and hes gotta set up the game to win etc etc

as SK hes basically just playing for himself, so do you really think he'd shoot hime there? i mean i dont know dofla well enough so maybe you'll have more insight there than me, but feels like a no

It is a stretch, it's why I opened today saying I'd prefer to lynch Gad. But with Gad having being jailed the previous night, we have an explanation for Mango's failed result, which indicates that he's at least a tracker. I don't see Mafia having a tracker and a watcher. I do need to correct my statement about Dofla having been jailed though, because he hasn't been.

Like when it comes to brass tacks, I'm not comfortable with the clearance of Dofla being "he wouldn't shoot hime". It's a bit weak. Ultimately if it's only a serial left then I don't think your kill will clear anyone though, because like I mentioned earlier, a Serial having kill immunity is plausible enough to discredit the notion that he survived a desperado kill so he must be town.

 

[Poyser]

Nibels targets

N1: Gram (1 kill)
N2: Mango (tho mango still got a result so no block) (3 kills)
N3: Gad (tho mango claims being blocked) (1 kill (other was claimed by vig))
N4: Gad and Mango (0 kills)

 

[Poyser]

It is a stretch, it's why I opened today saying I'd prefer to lynch Gad. But with Gad having being jailed the previous night, we have an explanation for Mango's failed result, which indicates that he's at least a tracker. I don't see Mafia having a tracker and a watcher. I do need to correct my statement about Dofla having been jailed though, because he hasn't been.

Like when it comes to brass tacks, I'm not comfortable with the clearance of Dofla being "he wouldn't shoot hime". It's a bit weak. Ultimately if it's only a serial left then I don't think your kill will clear anyone though, because like I mentioned earlier, a Serial having kill immunity is plausible enough to discredit the notion that he survived a desperado kill so he must be town.

yeah my kill gonan be pointless and im pretty much just doing it to clear myself up lol

assuming gad flips mafia tho, flip mango tomorrow. bet

 

[Ratchet]

The only real angle I can see for Mango to be Mafia here is that Mafia have a rolewatcher and a tracker, and no Godfather(?), with the intent being that Mafia have the tracker as a claimable with the rolewatcher being too dangerous to claim. I guess it can fit.

 

[Poyser]

From the perspective of mangos actions

N1: Predecessor MIA (1 kill)
N2: Tracked cubey nowhere (3 kills)
N3: Claims block (1 kill)
N4: Blocked (0 kills)

Tho did you say mango tried to track gad on N3? I suppose that does lend credence to the failed result not being a block actually. I'd forgot his claimed target