• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Elden Ring Mafia

Reader mode
Idk what to tell you guys tbh, I'm disappointed I couldn't contribute more than this but then again you know how jaded I am these days.

Though I gotta mention that Poysers point that it's somehow suspicious that I didn't mention him in my reads is whack. His other points have merit but that one is weird, if I had an opinion on you I woulda put it up there. If you really want my opinion, it's "he appears sound so far but it's Poyser so that's not worth a town read".

Ima just vote my one scum read

vote Ekko
 
Is his contribution towards the aurelians lynch not worthy of anything?
 
Might as well claim, Tweet, because that answer leaves much to be desired. Not gonna move my vote tbh.
 
RDK said:
Is his contribution towards the aurelians lynch not worthy of anything?
Click to expand...
Now that we got the flip it might be, but I didn't know what Aurelian was gonna flip when I made my reads yesterday so I couldn't exactly give him town points for that yet. Again, it's irrelevant at this point since he's claimed indy.
 

Why is he your one scum read?

How do you not have an opinion on Poyser?
 
Lethal said:
Why is he your one scum read?

How do you not have an opinion on Poyser?
Click to expand...
Bro the opinion I had on him yesterday is right there, and as of right now my opinion is completely whatever since he's claimed indy.

Heck I even said his other points have merit, I haven't contributed shit all game
 
Hans Tweetenberg said:
Now that we got the flip it might be, but I didn't know what Aurelian was gonna flip when I made my reads yesterday so I couldn't exactly give him town points for that yet. Again, it's irrelevant at this point since he's claimed indy.
Click to expand...
It's not irrelevant because he's claimed pro-town indie and been one of the key players in driving home a scum lynch so I want to know if you trust him or not. Right now I do but it sounds like you have reservations based on the "it's poyser so that's not worth a town read".
 
Why is Poyser supposed to be soooo suh-pecial that I need to talk about him in every reads list I make? He's good at the game, he's gonna make sense for the most part so that take on him is gonna be identical just about every game especially on day 1.

I haven't voiced an opinion on Ratchet or T-Pein either despite them being top 5 posters, is that damning too somehow?
 
He's leading a wagon on you so regardless of whether you think it did or not before, right now, your opinion on him matters. Which is why I'm asking the question
 
Huh?

Dude we're talking about a reads list I made YESTERDAY before we knew for certain that Aurelian is mafia. Did you want me to preemptively trust Poyser or something?

As of right now, sure he claimed indy town with no pressure on him so ima just take his claim to be the real deal and for all intents and purposes I consider him town. Doesn't really help me any though since he's currently pushing for my lynch.
 

The bottom half answers my question lmao thank you
 
Seriously idk exactly to what degree you actually, really think my opinion matters here. Like which opinion could I voice here that'd make people reconsider?
 
Alco said:
I actually believed he was indy and to then flip scum and be something completely different was hilarious.
Click to expand...
Personally I thought the chances of it being a fake claim were plausible, which is what I said to Ekko. I agree though, I thought the most likely case was he flipped Indie. It does bring me to another point though - the "remove role protects/add role protection" isn't a role I'm familiar with at all, but apparently it is conventional for the host. Given this, as I don't believe Aurelian's fake claim was host-provided, I suspect at least one player familiar with Gram must be scum with Aurelian. Not a damning point, but something to compass thinking.
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register