• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Elden Ring Mafia

OLU was almost certainly modkilled. If you read the thread you should be able to pick up on why that is. Poyser I think was through mech - if someone could remove the concept of Hatred, maybe healing him or whatever, he would instantly die.
i dont think he was a modkill. gram has 2 subs available being odd and psychic. it was pretty unfair to modkill the slot instead of sub it first
 
You have no reason to think there isn't a SK at all though you're just pulling all of this out of your ass lol

It's so tangential and irrelevant
What's your reason to think that there is a SK? We don't have any suggestion that there is one yet.
 
Why are you against lynching Ultra?

It literally gives plenty of information, and mostly clears Lethal with the odd chance he’s a godfather.

It doesn't give us "plenty of info". If I'm town, you're trading off a town Lynch for a single confirm. At best, like you said, I'm a last minute safe option if there is no consensus. But you are not advancing the game state by killing town me. It just minimizes loss a bit more, I guess. So, you should still extract claims from suspicious players today instead of letting them sit on the bench and spit while not doing jack shit.
 
It doesn't give us "plenty of info". If I'm town, you're trading off a town Lynch for a single confirm. At best, like you said, I'm a last minute safe option if there is no consensus. But you are not advancing the game state by killing town me. It just minimizes loss a bit more, I guess. So, you should still extract claims from suspicious players today instead of letting them sit on the bench and spit while not doing jack shit.

I don't know why I wrote if I'm town here like I'm not

:maybe
 
If I'm going to be mocked and shaded for doing this read back, then I'm just not going to bother. 1500 posts to work back through is a tough task when tired. Whatever
this and similar posts were the things that placed heat on lethal to begin with

until compassion was given. once people encouraged him to address the current issues and actually contribute like a townie would, the ones far earlier on even in day 1 reasssed their reads on him as defintive town

but if he's known for pulling the sympathy card and being emotionally aggressive as scum, why is this sudden no longer an issue? is there a distinction between his emotional aggression playing in mafia and being legitimately pissed outside of it?
it was such a huge point to people leaning scum on him previously. so why has that paranoia surrounding his possible manipulation stopped?

there would be less of a need for me to bring this up if rugrat hadn't implied he was going to give a chance to prove himself (without really addressing why he was a town read in general which i find rather irksome)
 
So then wolf me is just throwing out RDK's name at CFD for a laugh or what? I got a million other safe options I can offer up for CFD.
I don't really need to imagine a scenario where you could have thought angling for an RDK CFD was a good idea as Scum, do I?

Look, I can always be wrong. If you were, instead of getting into this dick measuring contest with Craig (who is probably just town too) to demonstrate some re-evaluation and development of your reads, in light of information that suggests they were off-base, I would have a much easier time reconciling your play with town here than whatever this is supposed to be.
 
Is this your style as scum? Ignore the obvious, pretend away other people's posts and then ask them the same questions over and over about stuff you could read for yourself? It's pretty annoying but I can't fault you if that's how you wanna play
Yes, this is my scum game.
 
there were 3 kills last night before the correction. I'm assuming mafia, SK and the vig. we always have SKs in our game so CP would assume there is one. that makes it very likely there is a role that stopped all the kills and it would be very risky for CP to claim that without knowing himself if the factional kill was blocked.
cp seem to have more abilities btw. also if he was indeed 1 shot and vanilla now then why not claim flavor?

cp is hiding something and not really being fully truthful with us
 
Wtf are you talking about lol I never took anyone to task for saying Poyser might be a harmful indie.

I'm not sure if Ekko is SK or Mafia and haven't said for sure one way or the other

You were wrong about Lethal being scum. That's what I was referring to
You took me to task for saying Poyser was wolf then changing my mind to say he was harmful indie.

I said what does it matter because I don't think he's good.

Apparently you can flop back and forth between Ekko being SK or wolf without any consequences.

That's hypocritical play.

Lethal isn't confirmed, though? Are you saying you have TMI on Lethal?
 
Back
Top