Game Elden Ring Mafia

[Doddsy]

no my role doesnt mention im demigod and no what r u talking about lol

i have not claimed to be protown indie lol

can u please. please. clarify ur wincon. who r town. who r anti town

u cant tell me my character is anti town m8. i know my character is town lol

Wait when did someone say your character was anti town? Are you Mohg?

besides top wagon

ratchet
poyser
kekko.

Can you give some explanation, mainly for the top 2

 

[T-Pein™]

Can you give some explanation, mainly for the top 2

no.
I dont like what they posted/are doing.

 

[T-Pein™]

Wait when did someone say your character was anti town? Are you Mohg?

tldr.
he says he is a target of the indie and that he is town.
means indie is anti town.
If he was pro town then ekko would be himself anti town but he says he isnt

 

[SoulKiller]

It’s not WIFOM, if you think I’m scum then there must be some kind of scum motivation for my actions? I’m asking you what YOU THINK they are

Huh? what you have done early on in the game is WIFOM tho and that's fine to admit it. Not sure why you saying it's not?

 

[The X]

@Black Pegged Dragon

here

You think Craig went from scum reading Yoshi and asking for him to claim to strong town reading Yoshi because Yoshi seemed legit about asking if he should claim?

 

[SoulKiller]

Let's talk about the veracity of claims for a second, considering our host is Gramma. Setting aside any prior considerations about how a person is playing, any outright contradictions they've said, etc:

What percentage of claims given in this game would be enough to sway a vote another way? I have no knowledge of this flavor, but I do but stock in the competence of the host. Between generics and the predispondence of fake claims, I think by default 80% of claims wouldn't be worthwhile information. Hot take.

There is so many characters in the world of elden ring and most charactes morally speaking is neither. Hell even the main character you play morally can be fucked up depending on which path you take in the story. I would say there is plenty of characters for potential of fake claims and such, I wouldn't really put my stocks that high to any claims except few ones.

spent around 200 playing this game. You can bet your ass I'll use information I have accumulated throughout my long journey in the lands between to detect the presence of scum.

 

[SoulKiller]

Pictured: Soulkiller and The Thread

Giving it a very good sniff.

 

[SoulKiller]

Where are all these "Fang" apologists coming from suddenly?

You have to play with the dude (fang) to understand where they are coming from lol.

 

[SoulKiller]

I think Retro (Poli) is probably townie. Although I am not really sure how her mafia playstyle is tbh. But for now, I guess I'll trust my instincts.

 

[Alco]

Time for a good old fashioned read back

 

[SoulKiller]

Aight who's down to vote Ratchet

I hope you lead by example next time you pull stunts like these. For I don't look fondly on such. You scum read the dude, make a case and push him. This feels scummy by nature, trying to test the waters.

 

[SoulKiller]

Time for a good old fashioned read back

beats reading forward i guess.

 

[SoulKiller]

am i not allowed to think out loud and see what reactions might come from it?

You absolutely can.

 

[Alco]

something from BLD or poyser is strange? who came worst from that interaction for u?

BLD. Poyser looks like he always looks tbh, I've played with him a lot (and I can never read him :slip)

 

[Arp Bladstrum]

Morning all, so seems whilst I've slept we've had 4/5 of a claim from Aurelian and Yoshi is looking pretty lonely.

@SoulKiller being the Supreme Warrior who caught me id out be interested in your opinion on Aurelian

I'm getting also getting a disconnect with Ekko, said he's on the list of names given by Aurelian but flavour wise they're all bad newa

 

[Dalton]

see my issue is if I say something extremely stupid like "you changed your avatar and I didn't realize you had the same name" it gives you and Craig and anyone else sussing me over these interpretations
But even pointing this out shows you I'm trying to be "cautious"

And the norm in Mafia is "no one can be that prone to not paying attention or honest, how is this possible"

take this as you will

I prob shouldnt play these games if it means it detracts from the positives of mafia, esp for players like Ratchet

But I don't wanna retire

I could believe that you thought it was two different people (Hell I forgot that you'd asked me why TPein to start). Unfortunately that doesn't change the fact that you were a bit to keen to jump onto TPein and it looks like you were trying to deflect off Aurelian (which is partcularly notable given the other point against you - that you were part of the crew that randomly defended aurelian).

Hmm okay lemme replace "interesting" with "strange", that oughta better convey what I think about it

Still fence-sitty. Pointing out a pro and a con. Not a fan mr chocobo

 

[SoulKiller]

You are allowed to do that.

I'm allowed to say that it looks like unnecessary busywork on your part.

Do you think her 'busywork' is fake or genuine? cause that's what it comes down to eventually. Would this player put this much thoughts thinking out loud scenarios and psychological analysis?

 

[Alco]

I'm not allowed to town read you?

You are allowed to do whatever you want, (wo)man, I'm very liberal.

Just feels uneasy coming from someone I don't have down as town myself.

 

[SoulKiller]

Damn, y'all really don't be playin' games here huh, just Mafia right?

Mafia is soo much more than a mere game. We are in the middle of the battle field right now.

 

[Alco]

I'm starting to suspect Aclo. Very touch and go, asks a lot of empty questions but doesn't go anywhere and doesn't possess solving energy. I don't like how he approaches Fang's lynch in particular:







There's no gears turning here, he treats the lynch like a forgone conclusion. To me, it appears as if instead of enjoying the hunt, he looks over the notes and goes "yup, safe"

Enlighten me as to what "solving energy" is exactly. And what are empty questions?

I didn't treat it as a foregone conclusion. I treated it like a vote on someone whose posts I disliked a lot and who didn't convince me at all with his defense.