• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Elden Ring Mafia

Reader mode
Black Pegged Dragon said:
How the fuck is that role fishing when Tweet has literally made a claim?? I'm literally asking what the fuck that claim was?

When did I say Alco was on the table today??
Click to expand...
Tweet claimed VT. Alco has reason to believe it. Questioning him on it at this junkture is fishing for his role. You and Ultra both did it, lol.
 
Rugrat said:
Because I think he’s town. I’ve given my reasons that I don’t see him tunnelling right out of the bat when he’s a cautious player as scum, and I don’t see him doing the disservice to his team of ignoring a case on him as soon as the game begins
Click to expand...

Lethal said:
Nope. I’m not bothering when the majority of players suggest anything I do is shit, fake, forced and dumb. I’ll confirm for them the idiot that I am. Vote me if you want, it’s cool.

Rattled? I’m withholding comments at risk of mocking.

So you admit gas lighting and winding up? You know if you’d approached my case with a nicer attitude, I would have happily debunked it. You can believe this or dismiss it, I’m not fussed really.

Oh there’s the 4th player to tell me to stop playing. Christ.

Not bomb

I built a case on ekko and it was laughed off. I found connections between Aurelian and Yoshi that was treated as ‘shit talk.’ So I’m not bothering anymore. Anything I say is fake, forced, dumb or shit.

I never said inventor. I am benefactor. Nice twisting of words to suit a narrative.

I’m deflated and just can’t be bothered. More fake accusations.

Honestly, after skimming through this, I think Ultra looks putrid piggybacking off lizards stance cos he hadn’t (to my dumb, fake recollection) seen him sus of me prior to this.

Could they be paired? Absolutely. Lizard has made it very clear of his case built and then ultra building one.

Doddsy I’d be happy if you hammered. Could use the object nicely.
Click to expand...
seeing previous posts, rugrat and other's defense of lethal happens prior to his response

now let's dig a bit further here
 
CraigPelton said:
Tweet claimed VT. Alco has reason to believe it. Questioning him on it at this junkture is fishing for his role. You and Ultra both did it, lol.
Click to expand...
What? I literally asked what Tweet's claim was, that he already said in the thread, that was already public knowledge. How is that fishing for Tweet's role?
 
Ratchet said:
It's not really - it was to make an argument that I had not yet seen made.
Right, because most of your defence would have been "that's not what I meant".
If you think I wanted to spare myself an extended back and forth, then you're really not as familiar with my play as you think you are. It's quite simple really. I had noticed behaviour I wanted to call attention to, and I wanted to do it properly in the form of a case. The day started about halfway through my work day, so I couldn't really start there. I got back and after eating etc, ended up going to sleep. I woke up in the middle of the night, and then a few hours later got started on putting it together. That took about 2-3 hours in total. Not once did the thought "I really need to not give Ultra a chance to defend himself here" cross my mind.

As for reads, here is what I wrote up over the night:

1. Lethal - Lean Town. Should be resolved if Ultra is Town.
3. Rugrat - Null/Town. Don't have much to read from, even if he is broadly in agreement.
4. Phenom - Null. Haven't given his slot due consideration. Could be a blind spot.
5. Retrolize - Lean Town. I think some of her thought processes have been very genuine.
6. Ekko - Null/Town. He's losing stock but I don't want to hold his absence against him.
8. RDK - Lean Town. Looked pretty organic vs Aurelian, Ekko's incessant tunnel is giving me pause. Not because I think Ekko looks townie, I'm struggling to see his angle. Will need to see how his Day 3 holds.
9. TPein - Lean Scum. Who really knows with T-Pein, I think he has had some degree of manipulativeness. Think his flip is going to be needed eventually.
10. Poyser - Indie. Generally suspect he's probably harmful, but I don't have any real reason to get rid of him right now. He was heavily town read without claiming Indie, so he could just be telling the truth.
11. CraigPelton - Lean Town. His character claim is probably needed sooner or later, I do think it would be very bold of Scum to claim to be responsible for stopping all attacks. Will see how tonight unfolds, but probably not too interested in re-evaluating without some severe degradation in his posting.
12. One Last Username - Null/Scum. His Lethal vote is pretty noteworthy, other than that it's the same old AM. For better or worse.
13. Big Man - Null. I remember he made some posts that were fine, but I don't have much to work with.
14. Ultra - Lean Scum. I do think there is a viable angle for him to be town, but there is too much posturing for my tastes. Probably lynched Day 3.
15. Arp Bladstrum - Lean Town. I don't see Arp having the boldness to commit to a posting gimmick like this as Scum, moreover I think there has been too many genuine attempts at solving for him to be faking it all. Fairly comfortable with this read.
16. Evans - Null/Scum. I struggle to find much of a reason to commit to a town read here. I don't think he's scum with Ultra, but when I think about other scenarios wherein I'm wrong so far, Evans comes to mind as a player I've looked over.
17. Dalton - Lean Scum. A lot of his content has struck me as surface level, and his choice of votes have left much to be desired. Could actually be scum with most players.
18. Yoshi - Null/Town. I don't see much attempt to actually play the game, and most of his posting is just going with the flow. It's going to be hard to get much of anything out of him. Think I will keep trying, with him staying firmly in the POE.
19. Doddsy - Lean Town. I've liked him so far, would like to see a bit more. Reads at a high-level were okay but shallow, he is getting a pass through the game.
20. Black Legged Dragon - Lean Scum. If Ultra is Scum I don't see how X isn't honestly. I've been trying to read him as town to not get myself pidgeon-holed into developing all scum reads from one, but some of his takes have been bizarre. Proposing RDK as a lynch option was more or less the final nail in this coffin. My expectation is that if Ultra is Scum, he is going to be heavily against him tomorrow if Ultra doesn't claim any hide targets. If Ultra is Town, I think X probably is just Town with him.
21. Hans Tweetenberg - Null. Meta reads on this guy seem to be all over the place. I did not like the "I would lynch me D1" argument. Quite liked how he started D2, though. Hopefully he gets his edge back again tomorrow.
22. Soulkiller - Indie/Null. Lazy analysis says he just needs Poyser dead or something. A Lyncher. Not sure I buy into that exactly, but his focus on easy-to-engage-with discussion points makes it hard to town read. He could be anything almost. Big day tomorrow for him.
23. Alco - Null. Sliding down the reads as the game goes on. I have generally liked his posts, but they're all so safe and easy it's hard to give him much credit for them. I think if I really must pick a side, I'd pick Town, but not with any degree of confidence.
Click to expand...
when did BLD suggest lynching RDK btw? i missed it. thats actually bad for him because he town read RDK
 
Ekkologix said:
when did BLD suggest lynching RDK btw? i missed it. thats actually bad for him because he town read RDK
Click to expand...
I threw his name out during the CFD. I was rereading his interactions with Fang at that time so I was curious to see what people thought.
 
Retrolize said:
still pushing for a case on me after claiming you simply forgot you had read me as town in your very first few posts in the game, guy?
still going to unvote and strategically place a vote to disrupt the lynch results? still religiously keeping track of the time left in day phases, which is totally normal behavior popping in and out in crucial hours/ends to phases?

what are you doing, my guy

you come in, scuttling around, say "this fella is town. i disagree with a lynch."
and the next day what do you do?
"i was right about lethal, he was town, and anyone who tried to push him is probably scum."

i know why you've mentioned me. i know why you keep placing my name randomly, and it's precisely because you want this reaction, don't you, big boy?
come and get it
Click to expand...
The bolded is wrong I never said that.

yes I forgot who you were, there’s a lot of names.

not sure where my “strategic” vote was. Lethal is pretty certainly town and I disrupted the wagon. Very clever strategy

you’ve just thrown posts together trying to make a story up. I’ve barely mentioned you anyway
 
its clear that scum are good at the game, even if inactive, so it hasnt been very easy to have a clear direction yet. makes game alot more enjoyable and challenging
 
It's wild how many people are mainly focused on trying to lynch people who actually caught mafia this game. Really weird way to play!
 
CraigPelton said:
This is so fucking desperate :hestonpls
Click to expand...
How is that desperate, though?

If there is no SK, there is only a faction kill.

If there is only a faction kill, why is there an ability to stop ALL kills?

Not desperate at all.

You don't care about the existence of a SK.

But without the existence of a SK, your ability seems less likely.
 
Black Pegged Dragon said:
How is that desperate, though?

If there is no SK, there is only a faction kill.

If there is only a faction kill, why is there an ability to stop ALL kills?

Not desperate at all.

You don't care about the existence of a SK.

But without the existence of a SK, your ability seems less likely.
Click to expand...
You have no reason to think there isn't a SK at all though you're just pulling all of this out of your ass lol

It's so tangential and irrelevant
 
Ultra said:
If you don't see, it's because of your refusal to see. I addressed your case in brief but it was eclipsed by my claim and the following discussion. I think Ekko is town and sees my interactions as also town because Fang was clearly trying to bargain with the both of us.

Honestly, the fact that you were at least in a lukewarm position regarding Fang, and don't see that perspective, is eh
Click to expand...
i dont know why r u still crying about this. if u scum read ratchet just say so otherwise move on lol
 
Ratchet said:
Yeah, I don't think I believe that you putting RDK out there as a possible option to CFD was some form of reaction test, and if it were, the lack of reaction to that specifically should have wrought some conclusions here, and they don't seem to have.
Click to expand...
So then wolf me is just throwing out RDK's name at CFD for a laugh or what? I got a million other safe options I can offer up for CFD.
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top