• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked My Hero Academia Mafia Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Anyway at this point I’m down to lynch either gad or fang. I’d prefer fang but poe looking worse and worse for gad by the minute

I won’t be voting haza
 
Poyser said:
I don’t think what you’re pushing makes any sense. If I’m the cop and I see my result flips and it was wrong, my first assumption wouldn’t be “my role is faulty I can’t trust it” it would be “guess I was messed with”. Theres no reason to assume he shouldn’t trust his town result lol
Click to expand...
Well now you're being silly, I'm starting to feel like you're just arguing to reaffirm your positions rather than actually weighing the merits of it. I mean, just earlier we had you insist poisons resolve within 1 phase which simply isn't done here, also had you argue the existance of a Godfather and no cop.

If I'm cop, and my result is proven to be messed with, I absolutely begin to second guess my role because I would know I just hard town read the player they used their lawyer on, presumably that would have tipped scum off. I don't then insist that my result from last might must be true, because scum would have had every reason to interfere with it.

It's true that there isn't much reason for him as scum to fake an innocent on a team mate that's guilty, but to be honest, I still think he has a good chance of being the Indie Serial. I know you insist it must be Fang and all but I'm not going to narrow my solving down to what your reads are when we don't overlap there.
 
Ultra said:
He was breadcrumbing, that's not really him resigning himself.

I do think him tying himself to her is slightly risky business.
Click to expand...
I wouldn’t call it a breadcrumb. He outright said she was town and doesn’t need to claim
 
Ratchet said:
Well now you're being silly, I'm starting to feel like you're just arguing to reaffirm your positions rather than actually weighing the merits of it. I mean, just earlier we had you insist poisons resolve within 1 phase which simply isn't done here, also had you argue the existance of a Godfather and no cop.

If I'm cop, and my result is proven to be messed with, I absolutely begin to second guess my role because I would know I just hard town read the player they used their lawyer on, presumably that would have tipped scum off. I don't then insist that my result from last might must be true, because scum would have had every reason to interfere with it.

It's true that there isn't much reason for him as scum to fake an innocent on a team mate that's guilty, but to be honest, I still think he has a good chance of being the Indie Serial. I know you insist it must be Fang and all but I'm not going to narrow my solving down to what your reads are when we don't overlap there.
Click to expand...
Stopped reading after you tried telling me something “simply isn’t done here” when I’ve played infinitely more games made by these people than you have
 
I didn’t argue the existence of a godfather with no cop either, that’s literally never been my position lmao u piece of shit
 
Ratchet said:
Well now you're being silly, I'm starting to feel like you're just arguing to reaffirm your positions rather than actually weighing the merits of it. I mean, just earlier we had you insist poisons resolve within 1 phase which simply isn't done here, also had you argue the existance of a Godfather and no cop.

If I'm cop, and my result is proven to be messed with, I absolutely begin to second guess my role because I would know I just hard town read the player they used their lawyer on, presumably that would have tipped scum off. I don't then insist that my result from last might must be true, because scum would have had every reason to interfere with it.

It's true that there isn't much reason for him as scum to fake an innocent on a team mate that's guilty, but to be honest, I still think he has a good chance of being the Indie Serial. I know you insist it must be Fang and all but I'm not going to narrow my solving down to what your reads are when we don't overlap there.
Click to expand...

I don’t think the bolded stands up to scrutiny tbh, certainly the part about doubting your role. Cop shots do occasionally get messed with
 
I think it's entirely possible that the town investigation is a weak Hider (odd night), one shot cop, and a tracker/watcher. RDK can be Indie, making a hail mary with a cop claim, given that most have claimed and those that haven't claimed are very unlikely to be cop based on how they've been posting, and therefore scum lies in Gad and, if you insist on another scum member, one more out of Rugrat/Mango/Poyser/Gram.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top