Game Elden Ring Mafia

[The X]

BPD and Ultra resorting to the same personal attacks on me lol, so rattled

Get in the ground scum

Where am I attacking you personally?

 

[Alco]

I would like to know what the people calling my posts "safe" actually mean by that. What are "safe" posts? And how do I make them unsafe? Should my posts be dangerous? Should they be hazardous?

I don't think I've held back on my reads at all D1 for what it's worth, but who am I to judge?

 

[Ratchet]

Ratchet, I don't know what to tell you. It was a last minute CFD. I threw some names out there I found suss, I threw out RDK's name because I was rereading RDK/Fang interactions at the time, I wanted to see how people would react and what might quickly build. I think CFD is an option that allows you to throw out some options that might not be traditionally thought of during an actual voting phase.

Yeah, I don't think I believe that you putting RDK out there as a possible option to CFD was some form of reaction test, and if it were, the lack of reaction to that specifically should have wrought some conclusions here, and they don't seem to have.

 

[Ultra]

The disrespect for CP here, wow.

Not from me though!

vote Ultra

btw I have reason to believe Tweet's claim and I no longer think he should be pursued.

Provide your reason and stop coasting

 

[Ratchet]

I would like to know what the people calling my posts "safe" actually mean by that. What are "safe" posts? And how do I make them unsafe? Should my posts be dangerous? Should they be hazardous?

I don't think I've held back on my reads at all D1 for what it's worth, but who am I to judge?

Just positions that are, on the surface, reasonable and easy to agree with, but not anything that would challenge your thread standing if they were proven wrong. It's a level of conviction and aggression, to put it into other terms.

 

[Dr. Watson]

Is Retrowhatever new? His post seem pretty good and detailed - so I’d like to give him a town read

Is this info? I believe he’s town. He’s done nothing to help stop himself being lynched with a slow weak claim and doesn’t really seem like a scum on the ropes.

Whether or not you have info matters to me in determining whether or not I vote to lynch him.

No guarantee scum use their execute ASAP either. I was scum about a year ago with a couple of others and it worked out quite fruitful withholding it until LyLo - granted there was a restriction, but we still held onto it further than need be.

Ratchet can be town

1. Lethal
2. Aurelian
3. Rugrat
4. Phenom
5. Retrolize
6. Ekko
7. Ratchet
8. RDK
9. TPein
10. Poyser
11. CraigPelton
12. One Last Username
13. Big Man
14. Ultra
15. Arp Bladstrum
16. Evans
17. Dalton
18. Yoshi
19. Doddsy
20. Black Legged Dragon
21. Hans Tweetenberg
22. Soulkiller
23. Alco

My current state of play

I’m not a great scum Hunter and there are usually enough directions early on (obviously I won’t let scum dictate play later on). I’ll just find town reads and then follow those guys.

Not a fan of this TM

Do we mean a persistent inactive or an actual coaster where he’ll deliberately avoid key phases as scum?

vote retro

MORE VOTES ON RETRO

Defensive. Scum buddy probably

The only reason to discredit a push on another player is because you have a strong town read on them. So yes, I will load the question and grill you hard.

This is what he said which was similar to my thoughts

why are you so adamantly defending another player?

Seemed a reasonable piece of text but fancied sheeping Tweet as I think he’s town

^ are we saying this isn’t trying to discredit me?

I’m not that arsed about lynching Lethal and thought I’d see who bought on Tweet since I was fairly sure he was town

Lethal spent a lot of time tunnelling Evans, I don’t think this is anything I’ve noticed him doing as scum. He’s much more passive in my experience with him.

In terms of cases, scum are more likely to defend it I think. I’d expect him to just a pod mentioning himself and defend themselves whenever his name was brought up if he was scum. Now he’s doing the opposite

Because I think he’s town. I’ve given my reasons that I don’t see him tunnelling right out of the bat when he’s a cautious player as scum, and I don’t see him doing the disservice to his team of ignoring a case on him as soon as the game begins

I’ve given my opinion that I think he’s town

Vote Ultra

still pushing for a case on me after claiming you simply forgot you had read me as town in your very first few posts in the game, guy?
still going to unvote and strategically place a vote to disrupt the lynch results? still religiously keeping track of the time left in day phases, which is totally normal behavior popping in and out in crucial hours/ends to phases?

what are you doing, my guy

you come in, scuttling around, say "this fella is town. i disagree with a lynch."
and the next day what do you do?
"i was right about lethal, he was town, and anyone who tried to push him is probably scum."

i know why you've mentioned me. i know why you keep placing my name randomly, and it's precisely because you want this reaction, don't you, big boy?
come and get it

 

[Alco]

Just positions that are, on the surface, reasonable and easy to agree with, but not anything that would challenge your thread standing if they were proven wrong. It's a level of conviction and aggression, to put it into other terms.

Well okay then you'll be dissapointed in the future by my apparent lack of aggression, I'm afraid.

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

CP's claim is most likely town. to give that role to scum would just be giving them a provable role but one which goes against their wincon which is lame.

do u have any other reads?

 

[Ratchet]

Well okay then you'll be dissapointed in the future by my apparent lack of aggression, I'm afraid.

Probably. It's just easier to get a read on someone who takes more risks with their thread standing, if that makes sense.

 

[The X]

I said power roles could resolve him. He was right on lethal, y'all were wrong. Dead wrong. It's been a pattern this game.

Why you acting like this shit is confirmed? You keep screaming you're confirmed. You're saying Lethal is confirmed. None of that shit is true.

Tell me how dead wrong I was about Poyser?

 

[Ultra]

The very least I ask if I get lynched is to not give lazy freeloaders a pass

 

[Arne Slot]

Why you acting like this shit is confirmed? You keep screaming you're confirmed. You're saying Lethal is confirmed. None of that shit is true.

Tell me how dead wrong I was about Poyser?

Is this your style as scum? Ignore the obvious, pretend away other people's posts and then ask them the same questions over and over about stuff you could read for yourself? It's pretty annoying but I can't fault you if that's how you wanna play

 

[The X]

Ekko might be SK and trying to keep you guys on his good side. That's his style

Is Ekko SK or wolf? Because preeeetty sure I got in trouble for calling Poyser wolf than harmful indie...

You're not a hypocrite are you?

 

[The X]

I'm not fucking reiterating my posts to you every time you do this, go read them

I see zero points against Ultra.

 

[Dr. Watson]

No

y not

Because I think he’s town. I’ve given my reasons that I don’t see him tunnelling right out of the bat when he’s a cautious player as scum, and I don’t see him doing the disservice to his team of ignoring a case on him as soon as the game begins

@Yoshi Wanna vote Lethal?

@Black Pegged Dragon, @Ultra, Yes...

Unvote

Vote Lynch Lethal

Should be eight votes on Lethal now.

"tHiS wAgOn IsNt HaPpEnInG"

A shame Lethal wasn't around to defend himself.

he claimed that role and then said he wont claim character or role

tells me hes got more abilities at his disposal

also knowing cp, idk why is he hesitant to character claim lol

its food for thought if the time comes

Day 2 Vote Count 2

Tweet 3 - Alco, RDK, Phenom
Lethal 8 - BLD, Evans, TPein, Retro, Ultra, Soulkiller, Ekko, Yoshi
BLD 3 - Poyser, CP, Tweet
Retro 1 - Rugrat

With 22 alive, 12 votes to lynch. You have approximately 17 hours remaining.

*Will likely be my last VC of the evening.​

To be fair to Lethal on that point, this is generally how he will react when pressured as either alignment

Don't see how Lethal claims this if he's scum to be honest. Easily provable if he survives. Probably shouldn't have claimed the last part either way.

Could maybe be an alternative claim for a Golden Order blacksmith but I don't believe there are any. I think each character largely creates their own weapon.


What about it screams fake to you?

Most of this argument is a large dead zone for anything useful IMO, as it's mostly just fightning and the same points getting repeated over and over. Although BPD looks worse of the two coming out of it at the stage I'm up to, as their doesn't seem to be much genuine consideration of what's being said, regarding both the claim and Poyser's stuff about his vote on Aurelian.

Nope. I’m not bothering when the majority of players suggest anything I do is shit, fake, forced and dumb. I’ll confirm for them the idiot that I am. Vote me if you want, it’s cool.

Rattled? I’m withholding comments at risk of mocking.

So you admit gas lighting and winding up? You know if you’d approached my case with a nicer attitude, I would have happily debunked it. You can believe this or dismiss it, I’m not fussed really.

Oh there’s the 4th player to tell me to stop playing. Christ.

Not bomb

I built a case on ekko and it was laughed off. I found connections between Aurelian and Yoshi that was treated as ‘shit talk.’ So I’m not bothering anymore. Anything I say is fake, forced, dumb or shit.

I never said inventor. I am benefactor. Nice twisting of words to suit a narrative.

I’m deflated and just can’t be bothered. More fake accusations.

Honestly, after skimming through this, I think Ultra looks putrid piggybacking off lizards stance cos he hadn’t (to my dumb, fake recollection) seen him sus of me prior to this.

Could they be paired? Absolutely. Lizard has made it very clear of his case built and then ultra building one.

Doddsy I’d be happy if you hammered. Could use the object nicely.

it should be understood if your previous plays as scum were histrionics to get people off your back and appeal to empathy, you can't just go back to that

regardless if your emotions are genuine here, you should be willing to fight for your case if you truly are town, yeah?

this "look at all these comments directed toward me, it's a waste of time" attitude is not helping you here, especially with your demeanor

so tell us why, in this circumstance, we should trust the authenticity of your ire and why it's not telling of your scum play

Would you really rather take no Lynch than a lethal flip

You really get off on that case huh?

Nah, I’m a child. ISO me to find it.

Googoogaga.
You’ve had a vendetta against me from day one. Don’t bullshit me on it not being personal.

I think he’s being perfectly logical with his observations of the game. Who would you rather it went to?

See another example of just instantly dismissing what I say. No comment on ultra piggybacking Lizard here? Fantastic.

As I said above, ISO them yourself. I built one case and it got mocked. It’s all there.

I’m not frustrated about being pushed. I’m annoyed at the majority of the player base dismissing anything I say as dumb, shit, fake or forced.

 

[Arne Slot]

Is Ekko SK or wolf? Because preeeetty sure I got in trouble for calling Poyser wolf than harmful indie...

You're not a hypocrite are you?

Wtf are you talking about lol I never took anyone to task for saying Poyser might be a harmful indie.

I'm not sure if Ekko is SK or Mafia and haven't said for sure one way or the other

You were wrong about Lethal being scum. That's what I was referring to

 

[The X]

Probably? Or Vig. Doesn't matter. Idk why you're saying this in response to that post

I'm curious how people think OLU and Poyser died.

 

[Evans]

I see zero points against Ultra.

Why are you against lynching Ultra?

It literally gives plenty of information, and mostly clears Lethal with the odd chance he’s a godfather.

 

[Arne Slot]

I'm curious how people think OLU and Poyser died.

All that matters is mafia definitely didn't shoot either. Neither kill makes sense + we know from the botch that ratchet was a janitor target lol. That's mafia all day every day

 

[The X]

Stop rolefishing, Alco isn't on the table today

How the fuck is that role fishing when Tweet has literally made a claim?? I'm literally asking what the fuck that claim was?

When did I say Alco was on the table today??