Game Elden Ring Mafia

[Dalton]

ur not a new player im having hard time believing this slips by u tbh

disagree

evans gonna evans lol

 

[Emil]

Which one?

this pls

how did u not confirm this with the host lol

1. is it their next action permanently or their next action within this night
2. what are you referring to by successful? your upgrade or their action?

as in can u use it on a player in n2 and if they use an action n6 would it be upgraded so long as its their "next" action?

 

[Dalton]

@Evans please ask gramma if you can refill

 

[Emil]

ask the host if it renews

idk why ppl dont ask the host b4 they use their roles lol

 

[Flower]

@Dalton do you have your result list as well?

 

[Dr. Watson]

there's actually a play here where we rush vote doddsy now so he doesnt have the chance to post a heal

then if bpd survives we know he's scum with doddsy

then again if bpd is town we're fucking ourselves over lol

tru

i dunno, because im stuck really wanting to empathize with BPD on the basis of actual respect

although BPDs claim is, again, in a sense very convenient. lethal may actually be town - there's some connection from their last interaction i just am trying to understand, some reason why BPD would want a lethal lynch over anyone else

 

[Emil]

there's actually a play here where we rush vote doddsy now so he doesnt have the chance to post a heal

then if bpd survives we know he's scum with doddsy

then again if bpd is town we're fucking ourselves over lol

i like how u think lol

down for it tbh lmfao

 

[Evans]

ur not a new player im having hard time believing this slips by u tbh

It’s a meta thing but you do you mate

 

[Flower]

i like how u think lol

down for it tbh lmfao

We all posted except for Doddsy, right?

 

[Big Man]

so if scum posioned BPD then the healer wouldn't be scum as well.

the alternative is Doddsy is just the poisoner and was told there's no healer.

 

[Emil]

We all posted except for Doddsy, right?

and lethal i think

 

[The X]

How many in the list are people Lethal would be familiar with and vice versa?

One of Doddsy's first posts.

Although I also think it's a bit premature as I think Lethal is capable of posting early if the times align, I'm not sure I'd put it down to fear

Literally defending Lethal posts early start of the game.

Probably the Golden Order if anything

This is a bit odd to say 6 pages in when you've been sort of the first read thrown out

This is literally the only interaction Doddsy ever makes with Lethal in this game.

Well I have spent 90 minutes reading back and feel like I absorbed none of it.

A lot of the discussion seemed to revolve around the same points over and over which means I'm probably missing some detail.

Alco, Haza, Evans, Ekko, Retro all looking town to me so far, probably in that order. Posyer, CP, Ultra, Ratchet all look fine to me as well but I'm not fully willing to cement it.

Abi's points earlier on about getting the game started were super weird and seemed like trying to force content.

Gonna sheep a point I think Poyser made on TP early that he claimed his role right away when he never claims which does have me wary to a degree.

Arp has posted little of actual game substance (I do enjoy his posts though) but did pop his vote down on Aurelian so that could be worth noting depening on what he flips.

Kind of wary of Tweet as well as his observations weren't anything fantastic from what he posted but doesn't really extend beyond wariness

I feel proud I'm Doddsy's first suss, really special. Look who else he susses. Tweet flipped town. I know I'm town. Arp just probably town?

I don't fully agree with that reasoning as I can see why he would go to bus right away from how that all sort of shook out. If I remember right, Yoshi was hard defending him and then got questioned on it, so voted, and then they started going at each other a bit more.

Mmmm, I find it very hard to buy that Dung Eater would be a pro town indy. 5 bodies specifically makes a lot of sesne flavour wise, but it makes a lot more sense if you're the SK here to be honest.

Why Lethal?

Agreed


You think Poyser is teamed with Aurelian, saw him fake claim indy and people not really move off, then decided it was a good idea for him to also fake claim indy?

Depends which version of Sellen, anyone who's done her quest knows what I mean

Can you elaborate on why Ekko can't be scum re: Aurelian?

Why Lethal and CP together?

Questioning why Lethal.

To be fair to Lethal on that point, this is generally how he will react when pressured as either alignment

Don't see how Lethal claims this if he's scum to be honest. Easily provable if he survives. Probably shouldn't have claimed the last part either way.

Could maybe be an alternative claim for a Golden Order blacksmith but I don't believe there are any. I think each character largely creates their own weapon.


What about it screams fake to you?

Most of this argument is a large dead zone for anything useful IMO, as it's mostly just fightning and the same points getting repeated over and over. Although BPD looks worse of the two coming out of it at the stage I'm up to, as their doesn't seem to be much genuine consideration of what's being said, regarding both the claim and Poyser's stuff about his vote on Aurelian.

Defending Lethal.

I am caught up.

I don't see Lethal flipping wolf tbh and would like to vote elsewhere.

If Lethal does end up getting hammered, have someone town read but not top tier do it, on the off chance he's a bomb.

I'd prefer to

Vote BPD

Defending Lethal. I am his first vote! Yay!

Also I wouldn't vig Lethal under any circumstance for the same reason.

I don't think it's wise to lynch him today either, as we can prove his role pretty easily and choose who he gifts to.

Wouldn't lynch or shoot Lethal.

I want town to benefit from his weapon if he's telling the truth, which I think is more likely than the bomb

They were throughout my read back. Thoughts didn't seem to evolve or respond to any information that came your way, and I disagreed with a lot of what you were putting out. I also didn't like how you started asking for votes on Lethal when people started to vote you initially.

Spreads some fear about Lethal's bomb but ultimately says he doesn't think that's the case.

I don't think he comes up with a claim that's easily provable like that. It's a death sentence if he is scum and doesn't give out his weapon.

Second options don't sway me too much as he was pressured early, and Lethal does fall apart when pressured as either alignment.


He was asking for super town options to be the ones that hammer him so they get his weapon. If he is scum, that lines up with a bomb who kills whoever hammers him.

Backs Lethal's claim.

I have no real reason to read him town off play, that's not where I'm coming from. I just don't really see any reason to read him scum from it either, and it makes more sense to not lynch him today than it does to do so.

Not that I have seen

Sits the fence with Lethal. Funny how he says he has no reason to read him town despite saying he would not lynch or shoot Lethal. Strong convictions for someone you apparently now null read.

It's a scum read, but it's not like I'm hard locked 100% or anything that strong


But I'm voting another WS player how's that work?

Confirms he scum reads me.

What did Lethal do that made him scummy af? The tantrum? Lethal does that regardless of alignment.

Defense of Lethal.

Does that mean your reasonins for wanting Lethal gone are the same?

Lethal talk.

Eh, lynch Lethal if you want to but I'd take my advice re: hammer.

Doesn't want to lynch Lethal.

I'm gonna be honest this is pretty regular Lethal play. A few games ago he outright faked cop as town


He was wagonned early, he shuts down when he's voted.

Defends Lethal.

Odd way to phrase it as charming and charismatic, he doesn't do himself any favours lol. And not really at all, two different skillsets

I don't know what you are referring to with that.

I'm talking about Poysers vote on Aurerlian, not you voting him. You're not getting "blamed" for it, it's just a reason I haven't cared for your play around it.

I thought you only had like 4 votes tbh, also made it immediately after I voted, doesn't take a rocket scientist. This is such a weird roundabout way of trying to shade, I mean if you sus me just say it?

Susses me.

I mean I sussed you in my readback well before I got to you saying to watch me in fairness to me.

Also that's totally 4 votes I was right

Susses me.

Do we have an updated count? How many on Lethal? You'll have to play for the hammer

Worried about Lethal's wagon.

Bomb spec is pretty much strictly if he's scum I think.

Mentioning bomb spec again. Poisoning the well.

I think I did specifically say I was voting for pressure/claim not to kill you

Reason for voting me, I guess.

I'm not open to lynching Lethal today if that's being discussed now, hider confirm it's not worth gambling on a GF flip

Defends Lethal.

I've already covered this, I'm not convinced Big Man is Rykard over Soul, I'm saying if it's not Soul I think it's Big Man. I think it's possible SK is lying scum trying to avoid a lynch by claiming the indy, he knows he won't be cc'd.

But it's also possible he's telling the truth and is the indy, and an indy lynch is not helpful to us at this point

Defends Soul and doesn't sang to lynch indie.

 

[Emil]

so if scum posioned BPD then the healer wouldn't be scum as well.

the alternative is Doddsy is just the poisoner and was told there's no healer.

so hes gna be a no show today lmfao?

 

[The X]

so if scum posioned BPD then the healer wouldn't be scum as well.

the alternative is Doddsy is just the poisoner and was told there's no healer.

I think Doddsy fake claimed healer off the fact that my vest 'deathflames' me and I die.

 

[Evans]

this pls

I’ve already said they get a notification if the action is successful hence why CP got one and RDK didnt

the wording makes sense, they get it on their next action. If it expired, the role would state it

 

[Dr. Watson]

so if scum posioned BPD then the healer wouldn't be scum as well.

the alternative is Doddsy is just the poisoner and was told there's no healer.

When did you get here?

 

[Dalton]

@Dalton do you have your result list as well?

N1 Retro went nowhere
N2 no use
N3 Ekko went to Tweet
N4 no use
N5 no use

 

[Dr. Watson]

I think Doddsy fake claimed healer off the fact that my vest 'deathflames' me and I die.

okay. so, you won't claim your role/alignment

but can you claim an ability?

 

[Emil]

I’ve already said they get a notification if the action is successful hence why CP got one and RDK didnt

the wording makes sense, they get it on their next action. If it expired, the role would state it

yes my question is which action being successful? your action or their action

why r u giving ur claim in bits and pieces its making it hard to group. does ur role mention expiring? can u confirm pls how long it lasts?

 

[Dr. Watson]

N1 Retro went nowhere
N2 no use
N3 Ekko went to Tweet
N4 no use
N5 no use

yup, we discussed this, you have good memory