Game Elden Ring Mafia

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
yeah it’s a system I built based off of an order that was already on WF, but we had too many games with inconsistent role resolutions and it was directly impacting outcomes (the famous roleblocked hider game some of us will remember)
yeah it seems ur resolution order is strict. ur night actions do not work at the same time even without paradoxes. i was hoping to get more clarity of this during the game but i understand that will instantly clear lethal
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
Fun to watch the game unravel and I enjoyed it, though I will admit getting day 1'd kind of makes my experience here very bitter for coloring sake, in this mafia game. Still, I think we need to give credit where credit is due to Ekko for helping steer town by accident on the wrong path on several occasions.

Either way; thanks Grammaton for hosting, this was a fun game.
funny enough i havent voted a single town wagon this game lol. they always get hammered b4 I continue discussion
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
@Ultra i did not imagine a scum claims tracker in day 3 with a serial still alive. that was insane by dalton tbh. not only one serial, but 2 serials, and none of them wanted to kill the tracker claim.

weird part is tracker being 2 shots while everything else 3 but I didn't want to role spec

his posts around fang were opposing the general notions of bussing fang so I didn't put as much stock into them. honestly thought that slot is self resolving after his claim in day 3
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
You didn't need to - you received a vest Night 4, which you wouldn't have had you been commuted. Assuming that Craig had jailed Phenom was suboptimal, because you didn't have that as evidence. At the very least, it should have moved Phenom into the immediate PoE.
we didnt know if X jails Y commutes Z would end with Z being commuted or not. apparently the answer is yes, Z will be commuted if Y was indeed a commuter

but seems like phenom wasn't a commuter so this lie wud be easy to catch with that knowledge about the processing order before hand

as easy as will be clearing lethal
 

The X

Marvelous
@Ultra i did not imagine a scum claims tracker in day 3 with a serial still alive. that was insane by dalton tbh. not only one serial, but 2 serials, and none of them wanted to kill the tracker claim.

weird part is tracker being 2 shots while everything else 3 but I didn't want to role spec

his posts around fang were opposing the general notions of bussing fang so I didn't put as much stock into them. honestly thought that slot is self resolving after his claim in day 3
D1 Dalton did not want to go anywhere near Fang.
 

Ratchet

Resplendent
Advisor
we didnt know if X jails Y commutes Z would end with Z being commuted or not. apparently the answer is yes, Z will be commuted if Y was indeed a commuter

but seems like phenom wasn't a commuter so this lie wud be easy to catch with that knowledge about the processing order before hand

as easy as will be clearing lethal
That's why I said, no reason to assume Phenom was jailed.
 

Grammaton

Consigliere
Moderator
wat

what youre referring to as 'commuting' is what we call 'jailkeeping'

A commuter in our world is self targeting only, which is why it goes on the same tier as a hider
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
wat

what youre referring to as 'commuting' is what we call 'jailkeeping'

A commuter in our world is self targeting only, which is why it goes on the same tier as a hider
is there not a role called force commuter that can target a player and force them to commute?
 

Ultra

THE BEAR
Advisor
@Ultra i did not imagine a scum claims tracker in day 3 with a serial still alive. that was insane by dalton tbh. not only one serial, but 2 serials, and none of them wanted to kill the tracker claim.

weird part is tracker being 2 shots while everything else 3 but I didn't want to role spec

his posts around fang were opposing the general notions of bussing fang so I didn't put as much stock into them. honestly thought that slot is self resolving after his claim in day 3

What should have clued you in is he jumped to the conclusion you were vig instead of SK. Only mafia could do that with confidence.

Also that I'm never wrong zehahaha
 

Emil

Average Diabellstar Witch Enjoyer
V.I.P. Member
same invite me to dead chat please if there is one @Grammaton

What should have clued you in is he jumped to the conclusion you were vig instead of SK. Only mafia could do that with confidence.

Also that I'm never wrong zehahaha
fair point

I put a lot of weight into his confidence giving me the impression its a townie not afraid of being shot. usually mafia when they claim power roles they r more reserved, something like Alco would seem more mafia to me than dalton based on that.

if I'm a serial killer and someone claims tracker they r dead lol. its such a risky claim for mafia to make so early. i commend the bravery
 

The X

Marvelous
@Black Pegged Dragon no hard feelings. Was genuinely AFK and felt I played better once I wasn’t being a dick
It never is hard feelings with you, Lethal. I felt like I was able to work with you in D3 for a bit and like, a little in D4. Those are the kind of efforts and rationality you need to play with. You know if I suss you and I'm wrong, first figure out if I'm coming from a scummy place or a townie one. If townie, talkie me through, help me understand. Look at how many players were wrong about others in this game, it happens. But having reactions or going a bit everywhere tends to only make things worse.
 

Tempest

Leprous Monarch
Amazing game! The most active I've ever seen! Congratulations on an unparalleled success in our community's history @Grammaton , you clearly worked hard on the game and I think the balance was fantastic and there were a lot of very cool and interesting roles. No night-posting definitely turned out to be the right call, obviously!

Personally I'm happy with how I used my role and a majority of my reads, saved quite a few town lives and allowed the Watcher to catch the second mafia of the game by blocking the scum roleblocker if I have that right. The Ultra mislynch was obviously a major error, but I'll chalk it up to being unfamiliar with him and feeling emboldened by Poyser and Ratchet's reads on him. I think I corrected well enough after that, though it was difficult to catch scum because a lot of them were still very much in the background and I was catching a lot of heat that I had to respond to from the insanely active and town Ekko/BPD, despite my confirmed town status. Feel even worse for my friend Lethal who got it even worse and had to deal with it longer than I did! Still bewildered that he was lynched after the GF flip. It was an extremely long shot even before that, as I mentioned while I was alive repeatedly, but in my view it should've never even been a thought that made it onto the page again after Doddsy's flip. Anyway!

Thanks for the game, and congratulations to the winners! Looking forward to the next one!
 
Back
Top