Fate/Mafia - Game Thread

[Grammaton]

It's part of it. Her frustration registers as genuine, she's basically moved everyone who has suspected or shaded her a bit down her list, the whole "vig me" seems like an extremely selfish post to make as scum even if jarring

You see my big problem with Juliet is the way she claimed - I don’t know who that served, other than herself

 

[Ultra]

TSworder your whole line of suspicion comes from the assumption that a standard vanilla role should not exist, now you're saying another claim wouldn't change your answer

 

[Ultra]

You see my big problem with Juliet is the way she claimed - I don’t know who that served, other than herself

I asked her, so

 

[Grammaton]

What do you think of Juliet thinking Hime is indie?

I don’t think it makes any sense whatsoever

 

[Grammaton]

I asked her, so

Oh

Er, why?

 

[TSworder]

TSworder your whole line of suspicion comes from the assumption that a standard vanilla role should not exist, now you're saying another claim wouldn't change your answer

Yes, a flip would change my answer not a random claim

 

[Grammaton]

TSworder your whole line of suspicion comes from the assumption that a standard vanilla role should not exist, now you're saying another claim wouldn't change your answer

See, that’s a good argument

 

[Ultra]

Oh

Er, why?

Rolling of the wrist, essentially, I saw her/Kurumi were top candidates for today and just advanced to the claim but instead of thumbing around the whole day.

 

[Ultra]

Yes, a flip would change my answer not a random claim

Hm

I'll be a bit more transparent here, I think you've identified a very safe angle to take here in regards to Juliet, and now your burden of evidence to come out of lynching her would be that she has to be flipped, which is rather convenient and comes at a rather big cost to prove a point which you just thought up of

 

[Grammaton]

T-Pein - 11 (Evans, Juliet, Ultra, TSworder, Lethal, Cubey, Kurumi, Aurelian, Black Pegged Dragon, Grammaton, T-Pein)

From my POV, Juliet, TSworder, Cubey and Kurumi are the persons of interest here. Gonna dig up their posts where they move in

 

[Aurelian]

I don’t think it makes any sense whatsoever

Agreed that it doesn't which is why I'd like to flip Hime.

 

[Grammaton]

Agreed that it doesn't which is why I'd like to flip Hime.

Unless I’m massively misremembering this, Juliet accused hime right?

Why would you flip the victim of the nonsense accusation rather than the accuser?

 

[Dalton]

Because unless your claim is exactly vanilla town, or something that specifically interacts with vanilla town, there’s no way you can say with certainty that there must be vanilla roles

I understand the logic behind everyone having the same 2 seal abilities, that makes sense, however one of them literally doesn’t work with a vanilla claim so my question is what does that actually look like in a PM? it’s a junk interaction and just strikes me as sloppy and misleading

Exactly like it does in every other PM?

It is explicitly stated that everyone will receive these abilities, so just because a hypothetical vanilla town doesn't have use for one of them, doesn't mean they wouldn't be allocated the ability for the sake of consistency.

This isn't to say that I can guarantee there are vanilla townies (I think we have seen enough to know this is the case, though). I just don't think the seal-abilities would impact whether there are vanillas or not.

Also,, as I said in my other post, there are roles that give other people actions - so there could be a use case for the 1-seal ability.

 

[Grammaton]

Exactly like it does in every other PM?

It is explicitly stated that everyone will receive these abilities, so just because a hypothetical vanilla town doesn't have use for one of them, doesn't mean they wouldn't be allocated the ability for the sake of consistency.

This isn't to say that I can guarantee there are vanilla townies (I think we have seen enough to know this is the case, though). I just don't think the seal-abilities would impact whether there are vanillas or not.

Also,, as I said in my other post, there are roles that give other people actions - so there could be a use case for the 1-seal ability.

The issue with that is that it’s making reference to stuff that just doesn’t exist. Imagine a seraph bodyguard protecting a character not even in the game, it’s on that level of misleading imo

 

[Grammaton]

Actually I went back and read it, I stand corrected

It’s written in such a way that it’s compatible with vanilla claims, so my bad

Still fine with my vote though, be interesting to see if the other posters are

 

[TSworder]

Hm

I'll be a bit more transparent here, I think you've identified a very safe angle to take here in regards to Juliet, and now your burden of evidence to come out of lynching her would be that she has to be flipped, which is rather convenient and comes at a rather big cost to prove a point which you just thought up of

If you think that there are vanilla roles, how many of them do you think there are? Wouldn't the situation become even more weird if they all had three command spells and couldn't use one of them?

 

[Lethal]

*This* is what you've plucked out?

Yeah. And?

Excuse me? Don't make stuff up.

Well, I haven't read most of yesterday, but when I left I suspected Hans, Grammy and you. I haven't lost that feeling yet, especially since something weird is happening between you, Kurumi, Grammy and Ultra. Clearly it's a scum push and pull there.

Finally it doesn't ask a question.

 

[Grammaton]

If you think that there are vanilla roles, how many of them do you think there are? Wouldn't the situation become even more weird if they all had three command spells and couldn't use one of them?

Do you think Juliet is scum?

 

[Lethal]

btw i'm p.33 doing a catchup.

 

[Lethal]

Because of everything I've said. Just read my posts. The man is full of shit.

Mate this is shitty. You're not the type to not repeat it until ears bleed, but you give off the "just read them."

I'm overtaken by shock.

So, Lethal, who do you scumread?

Tweet

Can I ask what happened with Pein in a nutshell?

He's a pathetic troll who should've been day 0'd