• We are currently rolling out incremental alterations to the forum. Don't freak! You aren't going crazy.

Game Ranked My Hero Academia Mafia Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
What was in bad faith? That I thought all PGO’s were unlimited???

Why on earth would I make that up?
not just that but the SK thing as well, felt to me like you were playing dumb or trying to make it look like i wasnt being truthful because i had a problem with your proposal
 

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
If you are shooting Dofla, Nibel must jail Gad, or vice versa. Take that up with him - "my target was jailed" isn't going to be a satisfactory explanation as to why you're not dead.
or you could just get him to not jail either of them, muppet
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
I will say that on play, Rugrat is pretty different to the last time he was Serial. Not sure if there is really anything to make of that, but I'd be remiss to neglect it out of hand.
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
or you could just get him to not jail either of them, muppet
He has a motivated action, he should absolutely be using it to stop a kill. I dunno why this is so difficult, he has a good chance of at least stopping the Mafia kill if not both, it makes sense to use it on the PoE because it could, potentially, clear them. It's actually more reliable than your Desperado, because the Serial could for example survive the kill, so it makes absolutely no sense that we prioritise your role over his.
 

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
He has a motivated action, he should absolutely be using it to stop a kill. I dunno why this is so difficult, he has a good chance of at least stopping the Mafia kill if not both, it makes sense to use it on the PoE because it could, potentially, clear them. It's actually more reliable than your Desperado, because the Serial could for example survive the kill, so it makes absolutely no sense that we prioritise your role over his.
he can use it as protection and make sure all of the obvious townies are alive, which is infinitely more valuable than trying to stop a kill and risk messing with other shit

but whatever. im gonna kill who i wanna kill and if he jails my target because of your instructions and then you mislynch me and then mislynch my target who would have been cleared then that can be on you for being a fucking empty headed dumb fuck
 

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
protecting important players is a guarantee. stopping a kill is not, and adds a risk of messing with other shit

if you cant see the simplicity in front of your eyes then idk what to tell you, you're clearly not as good as you think you are
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
could just lynch gad
Sure, we could lynch any one of the four (you, Dofla, Gad, Rugrat). It doesn't change anything - one should be flipped, Nibel should be blocking two, with one left over. We are already compromising this for your sake by extending this PoE to Bachi/Gram. Which I don't love, given my obvious reservations. If we stick to those four, we force scum into either abstaining or just being outed by virtue of a kill going off.
 

Rugrat

Caldust
not just that but the SK thing as well, felt to me like you were playing dumb or trying to make it look like i wasnt being truthful because i had a problem with your proposal
How did I “play dumb”?

- Your role PM says you shoot someone who is town you die. If they’re not town
you both die. Reconciling that if a hypothetical role is not town they die is fair. Unless your premise is that “because Rugrat forgot that some SK’s have a BP perk”, he is playing dumb.

- Me saying that PGO’s are unlimited is perfectly fine and I 1000% stand by it. If you find me a single PGO that says 1 shot, or that only targets on the first player that shoots you - I’ll give you the benefit of the doubt.
 

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
How did I “play dumb”?

- Your role PM says you shoot someone who is town you die. If they’re not town
you both die. Reconciling that if a hypothetical role is not town they die is fair. Unless your premise is that “because Rugrat forgot that some SK’s have a BP perk”, he is playing dumb.

- Me saying that PGO’s are unlimited is perfectly fine and I 1000% stand by it. If you find me a single PGO that says 1 shot, or that only targets on the first player that shoots you - I’ll give you the benefit of the doubt.
why do i need the benefit of the doubt exactly?
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
protecting important players is a guarantee. stopping a kill is not, and adds a risk of messing with other shit

if you cant see the simplicity in front of your eyes then idk what to tell you, you're clearly not as good as you think you are
Huh? We have a jailer that can block, we have two scum factions with 1 member each maximum, why would we not be using blocks in the PoE?
 

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
i thought you were playing dumb because ultra brought up the SK being BP and providing a false positive as soon as you mentioned it
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
Your argument would make some sense if you could argue that scum just WIFOM the kill between two members, that's obviously not going to be the case here. Makes absolutely no sense at all to be using the jail to protect players.
 

Poyser

Moderator
Moderator
Huh? We have a jailer that can block, we have two scum factions with 1 member each maximum, why would we not be using blocks in the PoE?
because your POE involves me and we can clear up multiple factors of the poe whilst ensuring that good, confirmed players are alived to pick apart the pieces tomorrow :dumbpepe
 

Rugrat

Caldust
i thought you were playing dumb because ultra brought up the SK being BP and providing a false positive as soon as you mentioned it
Haven’t reread his posts tbh as he irked me yday lol, and I didn’t plan on doing a full read back
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
because your POE involves me and we can clear up multiple factors of the poe whilst ensuring that good, confirmed players are alived to pick apart the pieces tomorrow :dumbpepe
But the PoE is more or less set: You, Rugrat, Gad, Dofla. Then Bachi, Gram. That's it. One of the first 4 dies today, then the jails block one of those remaining.

In fact, this is what should happen, and it's what I'm going to insist on.

You should shoot Bachi or Gram. They're the only blind spots, and your role isn't all that reliable a clear anyway.
We lynch Rugrat today.
@Chairman Nibel Jails Gad and Dofla.

If the PoE is correct, then if you're town, there should be no other kills in the night aside from your own action. Obviously if it's Bachi or Gram, you have a 50/50 there anyway (which isn't fully reliable).

Absolutely no reason to move the jails elsewhere, there is zero advantage to using it to protect vs a block at this stage.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top