Game Ranked My Hero Academia Mafia Thread

[Poyser]

I’m confused about why Nibel isn’t dead either

Setup wise he’s lock town so this isn’t a shade, it just doesn’t make any sense

I still think most likely explanation he was redirected to mango last night, so not much point killing him if you can use him to your benefit

 

[Ultra]

On the other hand tho, if it’s a 1 for 1 there’s not really much point prioritising the SK over the mafia anyway as getting either results in one less kill. Could get the game over quicker whether rug is the serial or just the vig by just letting him shoot in the poe tonight (this is assuming gad doesn’t flip scum)

Ok well if we mislynch someone else we don't really have an answer to the question, if Rugrat is truly vig or if he isn't we'll have an answer either way of what we're dealing with

 

[Ratchet]

is there a compelling reason cubey cant be our indy?

I dont think I like the rugrat solve, but im struggling to find a plausible substitute

He claims Healer, we know there is one in the game from CP's role, so in theory should be town.

 

[Poyser]

Ok well if we mislynch someone else we don't really have an answer to the question, if Rugrat is truly vig or if he isn't we'll have an answer either way of what we're dealing with

Well not immediately, but presumably we’d have another poe target dead tonight assuming he wants to survive

 

[Chairman Nibel]

If we lynch Rugrat who should I jail?

 

[Cubey]

[VOTE LYNCH Rugrat]

 

[Poyser]

If we lynch Rugrat who should I jail?

Just not gad from my pov

 

[Ultra]

Well not so much - if he wants to be able to claim the role, he’s going to have to heal (it’s usually a day role)

That's true but the whole dynamic is cringe, because you can assume for this purpose he'd blindly heal and then the whole purpose mafia having this utility would be a roundabout way for Indi to prove his innocence.

Then there's the aspect that mafia is supposed to try and find the healer and kill them before wasting their poisons, but most SK's don't usually crumple to a single factional so bleh

 

[Cubey]

You’re free to jail me tonight if rugrat doesn’t flip sk (or mafia, but likely sk)

 

[Poyser]

vote rugrat

Whatever anyway

 

[Ratchet]

If we lynch Rugrat who should I jail?

Gad and Dofla.

 

[Poyser]

Gad and Dofla.

Or do this and mislynch me tomorrow! Fun

 

[Ultra]

If we lynch Rugrat who should I jail?

Uh good question

 

[Grammaton]

That's true but the whole dynamic is cringe, because you can assume for this purpose he'd blindly heal and then the whole purpose mafia having this utility would be a roundabout way for Indi to prove his innocence.

Then there's the aspect that mafia is supposed to try and find the healer and kill them before wasting their poisons, but most SK's don't usually crumple to a single factional so bleh

I think I’ll just save us a conversation here and agree to disagree

 

[Ultra]

Gad and Dofla.

We've already got Dofla jailed once, that should be informative already

 

[Flower]

Mango: Gad > Rugrat > Gad
Ultra: Rugrat >
Dofla: Gad
Gad: Dofla
Nibel: Dofla
Rugrat: Gad
Bachi: Rugrat
Poyser: Rugrat > Gad
Ratchet: Rugrat

Gad: 4
Dofla/Rugrat: 2

With 11 alive it's 6 to lynch.

[VOTE LYNCH Gadministraitor]

I owe you one

Is this your vote version of your vig shot?

Vote Lynch Rugrat

Listen to Dofla, that guy is never wrong about anything ever

[Vote lynch Rugrat]

[VOTE LYNCH Rugrat]

vote rugrat

Whatever anyway

Majority reached of this post.

 

[Cubey]

 

[Rugrat]

You’re free to jail me tonight if rugrat doesn’t flip sk (or mafia, but likely sk)

Lol Jesus fucking Christ

 

[Ratchet]

I think having the indie be healer is pretty wonky and not something I think likely. I suppose if the whole PoE is turning up town then it can be considered but would take quite a bit to get there. Essentially means scum have a free kill.

 

[Ratchet]

We've already got Dofla jailed once, that should be informative already

Please read my posts to Poyser as to why it makes sense.