Game Elden Ring Mafia

Doddsy said:

CP, Posyer and I are all pretty strong players, at least from my view.

I gave a large number of reasons, with quotes on exactly what I was referring to during my read back. I still don't see the entire issue voting with a harmful indie, based on what he has given and the claim he's made, fake or no, he still needs to try and hunt scum for people to buy it. Him being indy is largely irrelevant in this instance.

Becasue I read back, made all my points and you said I looked better, then decided to come back and call me scum after I voted you for the same reasons given during the read back. I don't know how to respond to that last sentence, I'm not outright trying to lynch you without a claim or anything here.

Click to expand...

But since I know I am town, and know you guys are wrong, can I consider you to be that strong?

Okay, but you keep referring 'people to buy it'. In your worldview, people shouldn't buy it. People shouldn't believe what a harmful indie is doing. The fact that you're still thinking a harmful indie can pretend and bluff for other people, but still you accept he's a harmful indie, is still a fucked thought process. It makes zero sense to side with someone you think is actively trying to harm town even IF you think they're trying to scum hunt. If Poyser's gig is up as harmful indie, why does he care where his vote goes? Doesn't he want to stir up the game and confuse both sides?

Yes, you did start to look better, but then you put a shite vote on me. I'm okay with suss, trust me. And sometimes being sussed as town is good because I know whoever is sussing me is WRONG. It's up to me if them being wrong is justified or not. Sometimes I understand why people suss me. Sometimes I don't. And in this instant, I don't really understand any of the votes on me, especially you. I've tried to clarify any issues you've had. I've tried to ask questions. I've tried a lot to help you solve my slot. All you've done in return is to keep a half hearted vote on me and frankly not give anyone else any thought. I don't think you've come at my slot with good faith at all and I can't really see the town motivation from your play here.

Ratchet said:

I will never understand this Daddy kink stuff.

As you were.

Click to expand...

Okay, honestly I never understood it either. But then you get called it in the heat of the moment, and oh boy, does it make a bit more sense.

CraigPelton said:

He's trying to shame people out of sussing him.

Little does he know, I have none.

Click to expand...

I never kink shame, baby, live your truth!

Ratchet said:

I've played with a few but it seems to be one of those roles whose terminology has gotten mixed around within communities. My point was, if Lethal is town his request at face value is just to have his item given to someone he town reads. If he's scum then it's to get someone he thinks is obvious town trapped. Between the two I think the town case is more plausible honestly.

Click to expand...

You're thinking of voting elsewhere than Lethal?

Is this day 48 hours?

Ratchet said:

Yes to an extent. In the Game of Thrones game, certain characters had swords. Players could send these items to a player of their choosing, or someone who hammered them/killed them got them from their dead body. Lethal claimed to be able to create an item which he holds and then can give away. So it lines up.

Click to expand...

I've also seen fake gifters in games for scum.

Lethal said:

Again, not a bomb.

Click to expand...

Two names you'd vote for?

Ratchet said:

Not really a fan of the sentiments here X. Does it really matter who likes who? It's not particularly relevant to his slot.

Click to expand...

My man, just making some friendly banter, my bad. I'm still trying to enjoy the game.

I read Evans as town, friendly banter or not.

Ratchet said:

Yeah, sure. It's not impossible. Just that the mechanics working as claimed all line up to me. Frankly I don't think Lethal, if a bomb, tries to get this cute with it. It could be that nothing at all happens too. But if I'm given a dichotomy here, I favour the town scenario over the scum bomb one.

Click to expand...

I mean, devil's advocate, could Lethal still be scum without being a bomb? I mean, the fake claim could just be for gifter. I'm not sure who started the bomb rumors?

Ratchet said:

As far as voting Lethal I will go there for a lynch if it's that or no one. I don't have much faith in the wagon. I can obviously be wrong. I wouldn't be surprised to see him flip town at all.

Click to expand...

Where to then, Ratchet-kun? I feel like Lethal links to so many people here. If Lethal flips scum, we could go so many routes. I will admit that Lethal unvoting me has thrown me a bit, especially when there's a few votes on my wagon and it's the one counter to him. But what are the other choices? I offered Craig, you don't like that.

Like I honestly don't think I'm reading this game THAT wrong. I feel fairly locked in. Maybe I don't have all the pieces right now, but I think I have at least some of them.

Ratchet said:

It's possible. The bomb thing came from "Lethal is trying to organise who hammers him, so if he's scum, maybe he kills the person who hammers him".
Once I've made my cases we can see then, I quite like the idea of flipping T Pein today.

Click to expand...

When are you making your cases?

Can I get a sneak preview of why on Tpein?

@Ekkologix is there any team unity between RDK and Tpein?