Monster Hunter World Mafia - Game Thread

[Flower]

Starting to get a bit more wary of how Nat has ghosted

I would be concerned about her, but she kinda wasn‘t online since yesterday.

 

[Magic]

I'd rather keep scum guessing about my character, you've already said how certain you are I wouldn't claim it as scum and most people seem to agree so I see no reason to put additional info out there

what can you tell me about imposter.

 

[Magic]

Reads:

Nat: I think I discovered her Town tell again, so lean Town.
Magic: I liked his approach towards Ekko and also him questioning the positive reads on him. Feel like it would be much easier for him to just accept Town reads on him as scum and not questioning them.
Lultra: Probably Town as well, though I‘m still wary of him because of Traitors. But what makes me view him more favorably is him reading me Town. Scum Ultra could just get away with tunneling me and vote on an easy wagon, but instead he threw a Town read at me and moved on. Town Ultra also knows me well and can read me, so yeah. Town lean.
CP: Doubt he’d fake claim Miller, so the guy is Town.

Kekko: No idea why people read him either way. Everything he did so far is NAI for him.
Melkor: Didn‘t get very scummy vibes from this slot so far, but I would like to know why he implied activity is AI for Kekko. Guy was top poster in Weebs as scum and other games as well. That‘s no reason to read or lean him Town tbh.

why do you doubt cp would fake miller? are you familiar with cp?

 

[Flower]

why do you doubt cp would fake miller? are you familiar with cp?

Played a few games with him by now. Saw him as Town, saw him as scum. I don‘t think he is the type to fake that.

 

[Magic]

Hey folks, anything I should know before I catchup read? only 6 pages so i'll be somewhat capable here.

Vote: Poyser

Frozen in wolf chat

not a fan of this.

mostly as it looks like he's going for the same town cred he got last game for scum reading him early on and not being afraid of him early but just doing it in a simple vote form here.

 

[Imposter]

He was scum in EastEnders, and in short I don't think he's incompatible with his play there no.

I think he insisted he had a gut impression that didn't actually exist and is spinning a pretty reasonable early vote into more than it is.

I actually think you should be able to see that I had the OP in mind from the flavour talk with RAEM and you could then make the logical leap that perhaps fresh from reading the OP Melkor's post did jump out at me. Unless you're saying I purposely misconstrued Melkor's post which is a stretch. It's not even the main reason I read him as scum

He was Scum and Town respectively in those games. Why is this at all informative or substantial?

It might not be but I'm still curious. I can see why you would replicate the opening post from your last town game as scum even if I feel like it'd open you up to suspicion more than anything else

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

I read everything so far , I like Ultra and Tweet, their conversation kept this thread alive, they also shut down the mechanical discussion, (was stated by gram that there is no point in discussing mhw lore), but I like Reem also, someone was bound to talk mechanical stuff sooner or later, and there will be further discussions when we will get some flips.
I saw your gth read list, I dont like the town lean on Nat that much, I personally cant guess her alignment from 2 posts
Well discussions are still going on, I will form a suss list later

I don't like that most of this are recycled thoughts of other people

 

[Magic]

vote lynch Ultra

yall should be policying him anyways.
made yall look silly last game

hello t-pein.

why arent you offering to sheep me? has something changed?

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

does anything else in his play ping you?

do you think ekko raised a valid point in regards to letting raem continue fluff posting to see who else decided to join in on it?

What pings me a lot about his play is that he seems to encourage people who are suspicious of him for the heck of it. If he actually went anywhere with it I could perhaps respect it but this way it just seems like he wants to act unfazed.

He wasn't completely without a point that letting people talk about unimportant things can still help you read them, but then I vibe way more with Ultras counterpoint that there's something better than talking about unimportant things and getting read for it, namely talking about more important things and getting read for it.

 

[Flower]

I don't like that most of this are recycled thoughts of other people

Okay, this post sounds Townie.

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

Yeah you should probably feel a little insulted...

I'm still leaning towards Melkor/Ekko atm. Waiting for something else to jump out at me. Felt compelled to look at T-Pein's previous games but there's little to be gained from what I saw. He seems to enjoy joking around and asking who to lynch regardless of alignment. I do want to ask him though why he has the exact same opening post as he had in Fallout and Eastenders though. That's clearly intentional

I usually hate answering for other people but I can tell you that T-Pein opens games with that same post 99% of the time

 

[Tempest]

what can you tell me about imposter.

I only played one game with him and he was scum, seems like a competent player very capable of fake in-depth thoughts. I couldn't pin down his alignment and mostly tried to solve him via interactions and POE. my general thoughts of reading his posts this game are that he's churning out a lot of words regarding a rather boring and easy topic and against a player who I get the impression is rather erratic and generally not serious anyway. my eyes glaze over reading his posts

 

[Flower]

Tweet can be Town.

 

[Tempest]

I'm not really someone who provides reads unless prodded for them or I feel especially compelled to but FWIW I'm not convinced by Ekko, you seem very town to me, CP is almost certainly the miller and I actually agree that RAEM comes off well in all of this. I also lean that felt T/T between you and Tweet

oh yeah and he seemed to just go along with the "CP is definitely miller" consensus but 1) we've only played 1 game together so meta doesn't apply here and 2) he doesn't strike me as a sheepy kind of guy at all, so this struck me as a bit odd for him

 

[Ultra]

I actually think you should be able to see that I had the OP in mind from the flavour talk with RAEM and you could then make the logical leap that perhaps fresh from reading the OP Melkor's post did jump out at me. Unless you're saying I purposely misconstrued Melkor's post which is a stretch. It's not even the main reason I read him as scum


It might not be but I'm still curious. I can see why you would replicate the opening post from your last town game as scum even if I feel like it'd open you up to suspicion more than anything else

This feels like you're moving the goalpost here. I'm not actually sure what you're trying to insinuate about his post other than the fact that flavor and flavor spec is useless, but you're better off just explaining what about the post gave you the impression instead of vaguely alluding to it.

As far as T-Pein goes, that line of questioning seems totally pointless. It sounds like you wanted to defend him here but then put in some pointless clause of something you're "curious" about.

 

[Magic]

where did u get the impression that i have him "confidently" as town?


ur flavor shud check out and make sense for miller. im surprised magic is the only one to agree and ask for ur character as well

all i got from the others is that u r unlikely to fake claim miller as scum and gram is unlikely to give a scum a miller fake claim but both of those r things that can be changed this game

usually tho a miller role needs to make sense based on flavor. otherwise the role is designed to fail and when a player claims miller that doesnt make sense based on flavor they will get sused hard for it


=================================


on another note its past 10 pages, so im at 1% full power now

i dont want to change votes much because it increases post count. i like imposter direction so far and wud like if every1 game comments on it



=================================


tweet and ultra prolly town for driving a dead thread when they dont rly have to i guess

these early town reads
tweet
ultra
melkor
RAEM

why do you town read ultra and tweet?

 

[Flower]

@Ekkologix when are you going to start actually playing the game?

 

[Imposter]

oh yeah and he seemed to just go along with the "CP is definitely miller" consensus but 1) we've only played 1 game together so meta doesn't apply here and 2) he doesn't strike me as a sheepy kind of guy at all, so this struck me as a bit odd for him

We've played together before

Although it's pretty rare that anyone fakes miller anyway, at least in my experience

This feels like you're moving the goalpost here. I'm not actually sure what you're trying to insinuate about his post other than the fact that flavor and flavor spec is useless, but you're better off just explaining what about the post gave you the impression instead of vaguely alluding to it.

As far as T-Pein goes, that line of questioning seems totally pointless. It sounds like you wanted to defend him here but then put in some pointless clause of something you're "curious" about.

I've covered the post I had more of an issue with, his read on Ekko in response to Magic.

Where did you get the impression I was defending T-Pein? You can't see any value at all if someone makes a conscious effort to perfectly replicate their town game down to their opening post? Evidently it's just something he does so I'll drop it but I wanted to at least ask him the question

 

[Tempest]

flower saying I wouldn't fake miller because I hated having the cop fake last time I was scum felt like an actually thoughtful reason for believing the claim, better than just lazily sheeping people more familiar with me from past forums

 

[Tempest]

We've played together before

Although it's pretty rare that anyone fakes miller anyway, at least in my experience

reveal yourself coward