Game Ranked My Hero Academia Mafia Thread

[Dr. Watson]

Actually if you read this with



Playing in the background, it makes more sense

Shoo, not in the mood

 

[Lord Melkor]

do u have basis for this? as in, how do u know he wud never fake such PR?



i think ur town for most part but this is the only posts of urs that ping me, can u tell me what was the point of this so early in the game other than force empty content?

Just kind of talking to myself, I decided to voice my thoughts. I think in my previous town games I struggled to make myself look town to other players, so maybe being transparent is not a bad idea.

 

[Dr. Watson]

Members and Wano?

it was members tgabks

 

[Flower]

I actually forgot how Gram is as scum, do you recall any scum game of his? Though also leaning town.

Xmas. He‘s not easy to read. The kind of player you best judge on pushes/results rather than play (same as Magic and Poyser).

 

[Flower]

Ig Nibel is having some fine cuisine, 10 courses or so, when he‘s having dinner since 4h.

 

[Ultra]

I like your direction

So far I have this

Am honestly impressed with Ekko's play. Regardless of the muh unbiased observations shtick this seems to be earnestly solving. He seems like he's hardcoring mafia which is not something he's done for a very long time. I like his method for now

Re: Craig - has done similar shit to me when I was town and scum.

The earlier conclusion I had over Fang:
As scum he avoids disdainful or snarky retorts early game. That last reaction from him sealed a town lean. That's it. Not that deep. Not even a full case. Just some attributes in line with his town play. Craig is making a mountain out of Peltonhills

Flower: experiencing some cognitive dissonance with her rational on players like Mel. I don't think that this is coming from her being flustered as scum; it's coming from not having the ability to express what's (I think) a gut read. Why Melkor, I don't know. It's interesting she's less paranoid over others takes on her and why Mel, of all people, is falling short of her expectations and spooking her. Don't get that at all

And to fully clarify since it probably isn't clear. I don't mind her doing what's her pretty standard way tagging to pressure inactives. The issue I took with it initially was she went out of her way to vote someone while the heat was still on her.
She's now moved on to a more organic approach without hrat and has been consistent with that, which makes me think it was just a self-preservation as town coming from her this time.

(Ftr I do agree on pressuring Nibel - it's just something that gave me a pause on how quickly she went about it, wanted to see what the hubbub was about, got my answers)

Tl;dr:
-Ekko's solves echoes previous hardtrying as town. He's not being obstructive. Can be beneficial for nurturing discussion and angles. But would watch closely regardless, don't trust him to not get bored and do weird shit that'll hurt my and others reads on him

-Flower right now has a very inconsistently consistent town reaction toward the above variables, am fine with her

-Fang has been given a very soft town lean due to, you know, being... whatever you call this kind of headache when he throws snark instead of conversing like a cordial human being, it's that

-Craig has an edgy name now. His pressure I think on me is NAI imho, but he does have the capability to gently agenda press if he thinks there's an opening for him to do so. I don't see that here, seems like standard reaction testing. Overall null, need more from him that doesn't pertain to just my slot

Hmm ok

I'm surprised there's no mention of Bachi here since you spent like 10 of 12 posts talking about him

 

[Lord Melkor]

Also PSA Ekko has proclaimed he will not be reading his role sheet Day 1, policy him or don't bother reading into what he's doing either way

He is engaging with the game, I see no reason to policy lynch at this point.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Fang, Gram, Bachi, Hime Town.

Ultra, Melkor, Ekko slight Town.

RDK veeeerrryyy slight Town (think he's trying to solve, but I can't read him for shit tbh).

CP neutral/slight scum.

You and Dofla scum.

I have similar reads, though I would say Gad is null. He may be telling the truth about trying because he promised Magic.

You omiited Nibel and CP, which is weird because you were voting Nibel earlier.

 

[Flower]

I have similar reads, though I would say Gad is null. He may be telling the truth about trying because he promised Magic.

You omiited Nibel and CP, which is weird because you were voting Nibel earlier.

I forgot Nibel and Reloaded were in the game tbh. They‘re non existent.

 

[Grammaton]

I’d kinda expect a town reloaded to be highlighting a scum Nigel’s absence here, for obvious reasons

 

[Grammaton]

Well, any flavour of Nibel tbf

 

[Lord Melkor]

Xmas. He‘s not easy to read. The kind of player you best judge on pushes/results rather than play (same as Magic and Poyser).

But you have him as strong town read still?

 

[Lord Melkor]

I forgot Nibel and Reloaded were in the game tbh. They‘re non existent.

I think one of them may be scum again.

 

[Lord Melkor]

Going to sleep I think.

 

[Ultra]

Vote lynch CraigPelton

 

[Flower]

But you have him as strong town read still?

I agree with his directions and with how widely Town read he is, he‘s more than likely just Town. Usually he sets people up to win if he gets offed, so I‘d expect at least 1 or 2 scum mates of his voicing doubts on him (the only one who did so far was Fang who I have as Town Independently of Gram) and nobody‘s doing that, so yeah.

 

[Flower]

Vote lynch CraigPelton

You sure?

 

[Ultra]

I think Reloaded might be displaying something similar to last game here - where he retroactively adapts his reasoning according to input.

Basically, he first says he reads Flower town because her claim is "fine", but when Flower points out her claim actually sounds scummy he goes "Oh yeah well I don't think you'd claim something so scummy as town". But that kinda undermines his initial reason. Bad.

Tempest why you reacting to me and RDK's posts on Reloaded but haven't said a single word about him

 

[Tempest]

Tempest why you reacting to me and RDK's posts on Reloaded but haven't said a single word about him

I endorse the points, nothing to add

 

[Ultra]

I endorse the points, nothing to add

That doesn't really explain your lack of vocal endorsement, not even a "we should get a claim here"

Instead you're on your incel arc and trying to only pick fights with the women...

On a scale of 1-10 how confident are you on Flower?