Game Elden Ring Mafia

[Emil]

I'd post the case about Dalton but I'm not even going to attempt formatting a post with multiple quotes from an ISO when I'm not on PC.

Instead I'll conduct a survey - who's reading him as town?

me but its very weak and i agree he needs pressure

 

[Tempest]

@Ekkologix you don't need to keep speculating about poyser. we have his role PM. anything he said that contradicts his role PM was said to dissuade a faction from killing him. irrelevant now, he gone.

 

[RDK]

Yes I received a gift

 

[Emil]

I understand, but is this town or scum? To me, this is exactly like the DBZ Gogeta hosted (don't know if you played). I was town and I tunneled a player for most of the game. Everyone said I was wrong, but I wasn't.

but u were wrong on me lol

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

Question for everyone.

Who killed OLU?
Who killed Poyser?

I think OLU is probably a vig kill which would make Poyser the mafia kill. And if that is true, it also means that in order for the game to make any sense, Poyser has to have been on point with his scum reads. I don't see why else mafia would care about the indy over regular townies.

 

[RDK]

Question for everyone.

Who killed OLU?
Who killed Poyser?

Town vig
3p

 

[Dr. Watson]

why wouldn’t you name the players? It’s helpful for town if you are opportunistically lynched

wanted to observe what certain players (the players i don't really know) do after certain posts and my exchanges with them. i wanted to see whether those same patterns from yesterday would prevail, whether unvoting may occur, if those habits would change if called out, and who's obsessively folllwing the time and hours and minutes, or if people would pop up way close to the end of the day or not.

if i think certain reactions may entail scummy behavior, naming who i specifically suspect leaves the door open for them to readjust their tactic because they were caught in their act
i dont want people modifying their behavior if i name the select few i find suspicious, because it makes it even harder for me to draw conclusions or close the door on the conclusions im making
arguably there's 1 person that will likely have the upper hand on this

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

There is a chance OLU was Vigged, and Poyser mech-killed. That seems fairly plausible to me.

What in blazes is a mech-kill and why does it make sense for Poyser to receive one?

 

[Ultra]

I don't really know how to respond to top point.

Not necessarily for Poyser being harmful indie. If he has claimed that he needs to help catch scum, then whether he is lying or not it is in his best interest to scumhunt accurately. If he doesn't prove useful, those that do believe him will doubt it and lynch him.

I have answered all your questons on why I'm voting you, don't know where you're getting that half hearted vote from. I did not really give my thoughts on other options that is true though. I'm a bit suspect on Ultra and Ekko. Ekko just hasn't seemed to really hunt at all. Ultra I did not mind day one, but on my read back I thought he seemed a little off and some of the reasonings given just didn't really seem thought out.

I have a few town reads to give too but I'm about to go out for tea so don't have the time to list at the moment

Possible yes, but I don't know why he would have bothered with trying to get top town to hammer him in that case.

A Me/Ekko/X suspect feels really phoned in

I mean they're far from uncommon reads I'll give you that. I'll have more to add later when I can sit down and outline my thoughts but on the move now.

Also lethal said he'd give me gift because I was the only one playing reasonable about it, and no I don't think I should get it, I'm not being overly town read.

Can someone tell me how far off hammer lethal is I just noticed another vote came on while I was typing

Yeah but you view it as lazy because they're common. They are pretty lazy to be fair

Let me guess you just took the 3 most loudest and belligerent players in the game and you're going to henpeck over the inevitable little gaffs and gapes that are ultimately inconsequential.

No, I don't. I view it as lazy because it shows me you quite clearly haven't made a effort. No player in this universe who has spent any time trying to catch scum has

ZERO

Reads on any of the 80+% of players below us in terms of thread content.

Dabby goes on the scum list. To me, that's a very easy self out.

As mentioned, I do I am out at the moment and don't have the time to outline them right now, will do so when I'm home

Alco not present enough to be worth it IMO

Rugrats, Evans, big man, Dalton. Arp to an extent because he has shown hints of having reads etc but mostly memes. They're scum leans. Town leans retro, ratchet, cp, tp, tweet, alco

Yes that's what I said at the time. They're it a whole lot of use without the background info though

I still find the absense of them notable, as it implies we're your primary reads and I think that's weak.

Top is bpd, but you two would probably be next in terms of strength. Ekko has looked a bit better today though now I reflect

The fact that you aren't able to explain your reads right now while clearly still being able to post isnt helping. Personally even without receipts I don't need an extended timeframe to at least explain my general concept behind why I suspect someone. You come across as not having formulated it yet and are buying time to ad-hoc it. Just from where I'm sitting.

Yeah I thought that must have been the also that tripped it up haha

Throughout the day I thought his posts were a bit better constructed. Mind I still think he's a good scum shout, as he hasn't done a whole lot of hunting beyond hyper focusing on haza which is not going anywhere

I need time to go back through their posts to find what particularly I liked and didn't like. I did read 1500 posts this morning so their is a degree of reformulating what I thought during the initial read, as it does slip from the mind the exact reasons

"Hey Doddy can you explain your reasoning for your reads?"

"Oh hey look at the time I gotta go but I'll totally explain them later after I have time to fabricate them!"

Funny enough his secondary scum reads aren't so bad but cannot conjure an terse explanation when demanded. This is usually a pretty reliable scum tell

 

[Emil]

you were saying I was scum before the JK claim

i dont think ive ever said u r scum. most ive suspected u was saying i am struggling to take sides because u r both saying some scummy things

 

[The X]

I'm implying that you're scum annoyed that something that shouldn't be discussed and is disadvantageous to you is being discussed.

So I am so upset that info got revealed that I double down on my tunneling of Craig?

 

[RDK]

not only the gift

he also need to confirm wtf this was about with poyser:








legit what was that about lol?

I received a message about having to meet someone in the hold on n2, I thought it was poyser since it is his characters home but I was wrong

 

[Evans]

I think OLU is probably a vig kill which would make Poyser the mafia kill. And if that is true, it also means that in order for the game to make any sense, Poyser has to have been on point with his scum reads. I don't see why else mafia would care about the indy over regular townies.

There was a botch where an attempted janitor was revealed. This would have been the mafia kill, no?

 

[Emil]

What do you mean, he made enemies with the mafia team?

he prioritized solving the game over survival, clearly
can u ask something more stimulating and pertaining to the game at hand?

 

[RDK]

What in blazes is a mech-kill and why does it make sense for Poyser to receive one?

Read poysers role sheet, he can die through a mechanic

 

[Ultra]

Also Doddy mentions himself as a potential gift recipient and i dunno where that comes frim

 

[Emil]

I told you why I sided with him, he's one of very few people who I can actually work with in this game, and it seems like a good portion of the rest are just off in a completely different world with the stuff they're pushing.

right if u have the game solved already by all means share it with us tweet

 

[The X]

BPD i still read you as town and get where ur head as at
but like, what has tunneling gotten you so far?
four "im not reading your nonsense" knee-jerk posts at best
ive been there so i totes get it
but imma need more info and using your tunneling toward other things, not just players

if you had to reassess your reads, would your reads remain the same if there's a flip today?
what has changed and enlightened you so far, has it changed drastically in day 1? what are certain things you think people should note and why?

I'm probably down with this tunnel. It'll go nowhere. It'll have no support, so it's just not best for town for me to continue. And if I'm wrong, Mr and Craig going t/t isn't helpful neither.

A flip on who, though?

Enlighten me this phase?

 

[Ratchet]

What in blazes is a mech-kill and why does it make sense for Poyser to receive one?

Have you read his role?

 

[Ratchet]

So I am so upset that info got revealed that I double down on my tunneling of Craig?

Your tunnel makes no sense either way, so I'm not sure what you think the takeaway should be.